I’ve been very impressed by him have to say. Not only looks a very good keeper but has an assured, sincere presence about him that for me inspires confidence and a belief in a quiet leader at the back.

Not without his faults but I do/have loved Vinnie however age alone might usher in a successor. Unsure on Sam’s longer term likelihood of staying fit etc but very encouraged by the prospect of him being our no.1 goalie.

Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

I've long been a Vincente fan because of his quick reactions, cool demeanor, and genuine humility. His lack of confidence re coming off the line for high balls, commanding his defenders, or playing the ball with his feet were shortcomings I've been willing to overlook because he made so many reaction-saves that would have been goals against other keepers.

Sam has been superior regarding "long" saves with strong hands, commanding his defenders (it appears), and of course playing with his feet. Today he made several kicks that were better than any I've seen by a Palace keeper in the past 5-6 seasons. I'm glad he's ours going forward, and I'd be surprised if his game declines at all in the next 3-5 seasons. Great signing.

Think VG must wait for Sam J. to be injured to get back...

I think the club have a good situation but that will need to be managed carefully.

VG has been absolutely top drawer over four years IMO but at thirty six there has to be an eye on the future whereas Johnstone at thirty will consider himself in his prime years and want game time.

Johnstone looked very assured and solid against Leeds and made good decisions.

I would prefer him to VG, he seems to have a bit more presence as well as his agility. Although his appearances have tied in with our upturn in form, so maybe comparing him to VG would be fairer after he’s played a lot more games.

Sam til the end of the season.

If Sam is fit for august, t hen long may he continue and his to lose.

This was once a quality forum....