This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Badger11 Beckenham 06 Sep 20 9.10am | |
---|---|
It's one or the other. If we take Gallagher on loan we can't have Bat unless we buy him. However if it is true that Chelsea will offer Bat a new contract on £100k per week then we are out of the picture I can't see us paying those wages for a loan player.
One more point |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Sep 20 9.11am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by mattteo
Yes, I have more experience and knowledge than anyone else talking here or on rhe Palace board (former player or not). I too have played competitive football in my youth and regularly discuss transfers with the President of a football club which was involved in the Champions League in 2013 and is now reorganizing in the 3rd division. I've written the following and have been right in 99% of cases. If proof of the future is not enough, then I don't know what is. And some of my older threads, where you can see how things developed: And if you want to see them all, I made a compilation. It might seem like child's play, but I urge you to actually analyze it through until the end and you will see that it is in fact a proof of making money like no other.
Maybe you should offer your services to Brentford, they are more open minded towards the transfer market.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Helmet46 Croydon 06 Sep 20 9.15am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by mattteo
Yes, I have more experience and knowledge than anyone else talking here or on rhe Palace board (former player or not). I too have played competitive football in my youth and regularly discuss transfers with the President of a football club which was involved in the Champions League in 2013 and is now reorganizing in the 3rd division. I've written the following and have been right in 99% of cases. If proof of the future is not enough, then I don't know what is. And some of my older threads, where you can see how things developed: And if you want to see them all, I made a compilation. It might seem like child's play, but I urge you to actually analyze it through until the end and you will see that it is in fact a proof of making money like no other.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Petereagle Brockley 06 Sep 20 9.27am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Badger11
It's one or the other. If we take Gallagher on loan we can't have Bat unless we buy him. However if it is true that Chelsea will offer Bat a new contract on £100k per week then we are out of the picture I can't see us paying those wages for a loan player. I am sure we would prefer to have Gallagher on loan than Bats, as you say. Bats is still a very good striker, but he would still cost quite a lot , over £15m maybe (my guess) plus still significant wages. So personally I don't think it's realistic for us to buy Batshuayi
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
coulsdoneagle London 06 Sep 20 9.36am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I thought this was a done deal. Newsnow reporting that Leeds are after him and we are also after Bats on loan. We can only loan one from Chelsea so I assume Bats has now become a possibility and we are holding off on CG. It makes sense. We should be using our loan spots for developed players who can instantly make an impact and we could potentially sign. Bats is a position we need a player in, he knows the squad there is a realistic possibility of us signing him permanently if the deal is right in the future. Suits Chelsea more as well as he is on much bigger wages and even if we covered half we would be giving Chelsea more than if we covered all of Gallgher’s.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Putitout Oxford 06 Sep 20 10.10am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Petereagle
I am sure we would prefer to have Gallagher on loan than Bats, as you say. Bats is still a very good striker, but he would still cost quite a lot , over £15m maybe (my guess) plus still significant wages. So personally I don't think it's realistic for us to buy Batshuayi It would seem that’s where Palace , find themselves. In many ways this is the Palace ,dilemma . Because there are two sides of realistic. Palace realistically need a striker of Bats , quality if they are to progress to any great degree. If that’s that’s not the case you could say it’s not realistic to expect much beyond what has been achieved for Palace, so far. Without goals we are going to struggle. Gallagher, is a good acquisition , even for a year . But we are crying out for goals, few would argue that is not a reality. Maybe loaning a proven striker could be viewed as realistic, if only short term. But the reality is it would be a sticking plaster. We need one on the books for a few years, that’s the reality.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
coulsdoneagle London 06 Sep 20 10.16am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Putitout
It would seem that’s where Palace , find themselves. In many ways this is the Palace ,dilemma . Because there are two sides of realistic. Palace realistically need a striker of Bats , quality if they are to progress to any great degree. If that’s that’s not the case you could say it’s not realistic to expect much beyond what has been achieved for Palace, so far. Without goals we are going to struggle. Gallagher, is a good acquisition , even for a year . But we are crying out for goals, few would argue that is not a reality. Maybe loaning a proven striker could be viewed as realistic, if only short term. But the reality is it would be a sticking plaster. We need one on the books for a few years, that’s the reality. I think that any loan is a sticking plaster. But what do we desperately need more of, another midfielder when we have Kouyate, Jairo, Luka, the 2 maccas who all play there, as well as Max, Eze and Schlupp who can also play in the middle or a striker when we have only got An injured Benteke and a perennially crook Wickham as well as Ayew who can play there too. If we can’t get one in for good, then getting a proven performer who knows the squad, manager and club is a good deal.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hudsoneagle 06 Sep 20 10.31am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I thought this was a done deal. Newsnow reporting that Leeds are after him and we are also after Bats on loan. Dazza said it’s a done deal. DONE DEAL.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hudsoneagle 06 Sep 20 10.38am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by mattteo
Yes, I have more experience and knowledge than anyone else talking here or on rhe Palace board (former player or not). I too have played competitive football in my youth and regularly discuss transfers with the President of a football club which was involved in the Champions League in 2013 and is now reorganizing in the 3rd division. I've written the following and have been right in 99% of cases. If proof of the future is not enough, then I don't know what is. And some of my older threads, where you can see how things developed: And if you want to see them all, I made a compilation. It might seem like child's play, but I urge you to actually analyze it through until the end and you will see that it is in fact a proof of making money like no other.
LOL there are times when I’d take a red card just to leave a boot in on you Mattteo.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
mattteo 06 Sep 20 11.12am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Ok. But enough about me, there is already another thread in which someone cites lobg texts just to show that I write too much. Let's get back to the other U21 players who were in the natoonal teams the other day. How about from the England national team? From center forward down, cause it's more engaging: Center forwards: Nketiah- would be great, but can't have him. Arsenal rely on him this season. Ryan Brewster- possible, but only on loan, Livwrpool wouldn't sell yet, so we'd just be raising a player with no investment income. Also, still very young and unproven for the PL.
Hudson Odoi- would not come here, as he has recently been on the radar of Bayern and Barcelona. Reiss Nelson- could be surpluss to requirements at Araenal, but would cost too much. Sessegnon- would not come here. Bukayo Saka- involved with Arsenal's first tram and not for sale from what I know for next season. To keep an eye on though (left footed). Cantwell- for me he is a central midfielder (in his youth) who happened to play some good matches at left wing. He is a lot older than the others, going on 23. His price is huge for what I think he offers. Central midfielders: Bellingham- 17 year old, just signed for Borussia Dortmund.
Josh da Silva- yes, good central midfielder Gallagher- another good centtal midfielder, but Chelsea never seels cheap.
Max Aarons- an often spoken name here. Not a bad player, but they ask too much for him imo. Justin James- now this kid was not very expensive- Leicester paid 6.5 million for him and he is pretty good for a 22 year old. Tariq Lamptey- Brighton fullback, Chelsea graduate, they paid 3 million for him, haven't seen him much, very young still at 19, he seems pretty short, don't know if he stopped growing. Center halfs: Ben Godfrey- good center back just got reelgated with Norwich, maybe doesn't cost that much, but we have plenty there. Liam Lelly- similar, relegated with Bournemouth, can play left back too, but cost them 15 million last summer, so they'd want a big fee. Jonathan Panzo- still very young, tried his luck with French giants Monaco and will this seeason play for Dijon, having cost them just 3 million. Marc Guehi- haven't seen him play much in the Championship, but apparently he's pretty good and with Chelsea giving yojngsters like Mason Mount, Tammy Abraham and Tomori chances, he might make the strp up. Or they may sell him and get good money, as Chelsea always does. Goalkeeper: Ramsdale-
Mason Greenwood- not gonna happen, already with the main national team Sam Surridge- interesting and cheap center forward, to keep an eye on Eze- already bought McNeil- not worth what they're askkng for Foden- not going to come here
Willock- involved with the Arsenal first team. Reece James- Chelsea won't sell.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
spartakev2 Anerley 06 Sep 20 11.25am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by mattteo
Ok. But enough about me, there is already another thread in which someone cites lobg texts just to show that I write too much. Let's get back to the other U21 players who were in the natoonal teams the other day. How about from the England national team? From center forward down, cause it's more engaging: Center forwards: Nketiah- would be great, but can't have him. Arsenal rely on him this season. Ryan Brewster- possible, but only on loan, Livwrpool wouldn't sell yet, so we'd just be raising a player with no investment income. Also, still very young and unproven for the PL.
Hudson Odoi- would not come here, as he has recently been on the radar of Bayern and Barcelona. Reiss Nelson- could be surpluss to requirements at Araenal, but would cost too much. Sessegnon- would not come here. Bukayo Saka- involved with Arsenal's first tram and not for sale from what I know for next season. To keep an eye on though (left footed). Cantwell- for me he is a central midfielder (in his youth) who happened to play some good matches at left wing. He is a lot older than the others, going on 23. His price is huge for what I think he offers. Central midfielders: Bellingham- 17 year old, just signed for Borussia Dortmund.
Josh da Silva- yes, good central midfielder Gallagher- another good centtal midfielder, but Chelsea never seels cheap.
Max Aarons- an often spoken name here. Not a bad player, but they ask too much for him imo. Justin James- now this kid was not very expensive- Leicester paid 6.5 million for him and he is pretty good for a 22 year old. Tariq Lamptey- Brighton fullback, Chelsea graduate, they paid 3 million for him, haven't seen him much, very young still at 19, he seems pretty short, don't know if he stopped growing. Center halfs: Ben Godfrey- good center back just got reelgated with Norwich, maybe doesn't cost that much, but we have plenty there. Liam Lelly- similar, relegated with Bournemouth, can play left back too, but cost them 15 million last summer, so they'd want a big fee. Jonathan Panzo- still very young, tried his luck with French giants Monaco and will this seeason play for Dijon, having cost them just 3 million. Marc Guehi- haven't seen him play much in the Championship, but apparently he's pretty good and with Chelsea giving yojngsters like Mason Mount, Tammy Abraham and Tomori chances, he might make the strp up. Or they may sell him and get good money, as Chelsea always does. Goalkeeper: Ramsdale-
Mason Greenwood- not gonna happen, already with the main national team Sam Surridge- interesting and cheap center forward, to keep an eye on Eze- already bought McNeil- not worth what they're askkng for Foden- not going to come here
Willock- involved with the Arsenal first team. Reece James- Chelsea won't sell. Not sure what the point of this post is, apart from stating the bleeding obvious...
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Petereagle Brockley 06 Sep 20 12.06pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Not sure what the point of this post is, apart from stating the bleeding obvious... Everyone is welcome to their opinion, but personally I am more interested in 'hard rumours' - if there is su+h a thing!
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.