This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
ghosteagle 04 Aug 15 6.50pm | |
---|---|
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.43pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.37pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.33pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.26pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.25pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.23pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.20pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.16pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.13pm
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs.
Work it out, mate. Do you have any numbers handy? I have seen many posters claim this and many claim that actually they don't get more in the UK than Germany etc but nobody seems to be providing any actual evidence......
I was questioning the idea that the uk is more generous to immigrants than other EU countries. I had read that they got better benefits in Germany and Sweden. Perhaps you should nip over to Calais and show them what you've read as they clearly believe otherwise. Not necessarily, if true it means that their reasons for coming here are based on something other than a simple economic equation.
If that isn't true, then somebody needs to educate them (seeing as how nobody seems prepared to set about them with flamethrowers).
I feel that Catfish has provided a full and interesting answer. The idea that we hand out benefits to everyone who wants them has been disproved many times, but the idea that they find working in Britain easier seems logical. Also, both France and Germany take more immigrants than we do, so the vast majority of them don't pass through but have stayed in those countries. So, given that the immigrants do not come here to leech of the welfare state but are looking for work does this change how we should approach the problem? Should the government instead be concentrating on cracking down on employers who employ illegal immigrants?
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 04 Aug 15 6.58pm | |
---|---|
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.43pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.37pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.33pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.26pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.25pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.23pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.20pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.16pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.13pm
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs.
Work it out, mate. Do you have any numbers handy? I have seen many posters claim this and many claim that actually they don't get more in the UK than Germany etc but nobody seems to be providing any actual evidence......
I was questioning the idea that the uk is more generous to immigrants than other EU countries. I had read that they got better benefits in Germany and Sweden. Perhaps you should nip over to Calais and show them what you've read as they clearly believe otherwise. Not necessarily, if true it means that their reasons for coming here are based on something other than a simple economic equation.
If that isn't true, then somebody needs to educate them (seeing as how nobody seems prepared to set about them with flamethrowers).
Or better.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
susmik PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 04 Aug 15 7.07pm | |
---|---|
Quote nairb75 at 04 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
they already get those benefits in france, germany and hungary. they aren't lining up in calais b/c of benefits. it's b/c they can speak english and have a much better prospect for work and education.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
susmik PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 04 Aug 15 7.08pm | |
---|---|
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Cucking Funt Clapham on the Back 04 Aug 15 7.09pm | |
---|---|
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 6.58pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.43pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.37pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.33pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.26pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.25pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.23pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.20pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.16pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.13pm
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs.
Work it out, mate. Do you have any numbers handy? I have seen many posters claim this and many claim that actually they don't get more in the UK than Germany etc but nobody seems to be providing any actual evidence......
I was questioning the idea that the uk is more generous to immigrants than other EU countries. I had read that they got better benefits in Germany and Sweden. Perhaps you should nip over to Calais and show them what you've read as they clearly believe otherwise. Not necessarily, if true it means that their reasons for coming here are based on something other than a simple economic equation.
If that isn't true, then somebody needs to educate them (seeing as how nobody seems prepared to set about them with flamethrowers).
Or better. From their point of view, there's no difference.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
ghosteagle 04 Aug 15 7.12pm | |
---|---|
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 7.07pm
Quote nairb75 at 04 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
they already get those benefits in france, germany and hungary. they aren't lining up in calais b/c of benefits. it's b/c they can speak english and have a much better prospect for work and education.
As has been said a few times now, the immigrants in Calais are not coming for some sort of freebie extravaganza, but come looking for work.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
-TUX- Alphabettispaghetti 04 Aug 15 7.15pm | |
---|---|
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 6.35pm
There is little evidence that the benefit system is open to abuse or that illegal migrants are taking social housing. If it is accepted that is the case you have to look for other reasons that make the UK attractive" The main incentive for migrants, whether illegal or legal is work, and always has been. The key differences between this country and other European countries is how easy it is to enter the black economy. The lack of a national labour inspectorate and, most importantly, the lack of national ID cards are what make the difference. There have been attempts to shore up the system in other ways. Fines for employers and landlords, labour restrictions on asylum seekers and plans to prosecute illegal workers and seize wages. All of this was planned by Labour to create a "hostile environment" ( a term coined by Labour immigration minister Liam Byrne). Labour also of course planned to introduce national ID cards but the scheme was scrapped by the Tories. Labour were on the right track and the perception among migrants that we are still an open house for illegal workers is one that has been allowed to continue by the coalition and present government. If the British public are serious about controlling migration they will have to accept the kind of in country restrictions that exist elsewhere. This is where the libertarian right and the paranoid left meet in a common cause. It is ironic that the key measure that might help control illegal migration is opposed by those most in favour and most against immigration controls.
Time to move forward together. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
JL85 London,SE9 04 Aug 15 7.16pm | |
---|---|
Quote Fazil Bawlty at 04 Aug 2015 6.50pm
You really need to distinguish the difference between immigrants (mostly economic, financial migrants), and refugees / asylum seekers, driven towards the UK due to political and social hardship. Many of those in Calais (such as the reported 13 y/o old orphan who has led his 8 y/o brother to safety only to be denied and victimised as an 'immigrant'). Fact is, the UK is only ranked 16th out of the 28 EU members in the rate of refugees coming in. Only 0.24% of our population are refugees. We take in fewer than most EU countries. It's disgusting that parties such as UKIP have made this a prominent area of UK politics. The 7000 or so people coming into Britain from Calais - most of whom will work their fingers to the bone to survive and pay into our economy - shouldn't be vilified but cherished as they prove the success of our nation which has historically helped those plagued with political hardships and violence abroad. We're a tolerant, liberal society, grow up.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
susmik PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 04 Aug 15 7.16pm | |
---|---|
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs. Edited by nickgusset (04 Aug 2015 6.14pm) I did say in my post that the crisis was in housing and healthcare hence that is why hospitals are stretched to the limit and the housing situation is so bad with immigrants taking it all whether or not it is council housing or private rental it stops our own youngsters and fellow citizens getting a home over their heads. Its not rocket science to work out that if a few thousand people come into the country whether legal or otherwise they need a roof over their heads and if they need medical care then our doctors and hospitals supply it. It has nothing to do with successive governments not putting the money in. if it was not for the thousands of people flooding our little island over the past 20 odd years or more we would be fine and get to see our doctor quicker that in a two week waiting time period Nick!
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
ghosteagle 04 Aug 15 7.18pm | |
---|---|
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 7.16pm
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is. Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason? If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally. Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it. Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants. The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs. Edited by nickgusset (04 Aug 2015 6.14pm) I did say in my post that the crisis was in housing and healthcare hence that is why hospitals are stretched to the limit and the housing situation is so bad with immigrants taking it all whether or not it is council housing or private rental it stops our own youngsters and fellow citizens getting a home over their heads. Its not rocket science to work out that if a few thousand people come into the country whether legal or otherwise they need a roof over their heads and if they need medical care then our doctors and hospitals supply it. It has nothing to do with successive governments not putting the money in. if it was not for the thousands of people flooding our little island over the past 20 odd years or more we would be fine and get to see our doctor quicker that in a two week waiting time period Nick! Do you have any evidence for this claim? I ask because without figures to back it up it just looks like casual racism.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Jamesrichards8 04 Aug 15 7.19pm | |
---|---|
Keep the immigrants coming in. Just don't expect British culture to survive, and don't expect British people to be happy about it. Because it's wrong.
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop... |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Kermit8 Hevon 04 Aug 15 7.26pm | |
---|---|
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 04 Aug 2015 7.19pm
Keep the immigrants coming in. Just don't expect British culture to survive, and don't expect British people to be happy about it. Because it's wrong.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.