This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 15 6.14pm | |
---|---|
At the end of the day Corbyn engaged in defensive politics, was totally unambitious and played for a draw. If this continues it will be less relevant to public opinion as less people will watch it. Edited by Willo (16 Sep 2015 6.14pm)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
-TUX- Alphabettispaghetti 16 Sep 15 6.17pm | |
---|---|
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.57pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.52pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.43pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.31pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.27pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.22pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.14pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 16 Sep 2015 5.04pm
I think you have to say that Corbyn came over far better today than Milliband ever did. Corbyn never came back with anything after Cameron provided answers.It wasn't a "Yah Boo" cut and thrust session. Let's get back to the "Punch and Judy" show instead of a bland question and answer session ! Edited by Willo (16 Sep 2015 5.16pm)
I really don't agree that cut and thrust sessions between political leaders is responsible for any political malaise.Think the issues are far more complex and run deeper than that. Today's PMQs was bland and boring and the 'House' was as dead as a mortuary.Hopefully this won't last.
I like to see Prime Minister's challenged on their answers and this brings about a "Cut and thrust". All Corbyn did was ask questions and meekly accept what Cameron had to say.He came back with nothing.It was the interaction between the party leaders which really made PMQs. It was not what you call "Playground verbals" but lively debate. Maybe PMQ's should be a list of questions given to the PM on a sheet of paper and he runs down them providing answers !!!! Or maybe he should sit in a "Mastermind" chair and a quiz master appointed to ask questions !
Far better than what we witnessed today. I kinda figured, what with you being such an avid campaigner and all that, you'd welcome the views of the electorate being aired. Wrong colour perhaps?
Time to move forward together. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Sep 15 6.22pm | |
---|---|
Cameron's point scoring and constant emphasis on the economy may become a little tiring and the Tories may have to rethink their leadership soon enough. May make Corbyn seem like a political genius and genuine reformer whilst revealing the Tories as the 'crab people' they really are.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 15 6.28pm | |
---|---|
Quote -TUX- at 16 Sep 2015 6.17pm
I kinda figured, what with you being such an avid campaigner and all that, you'd welcome the views of the electorate being aired. I've not complained about the views of the electorate being aired.But 6 questions hardly reflect the public mood ! I would far rather Paxman ask the PM and really 'grill' him on his answers.Not "Comrade Corbyn" with his form of extreme socialism who just asks questions and never "drills down" into the reply.All very bland and soporific.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 15 6.29pm | |
---|---|
Quote ASCPFC at 16 Sep 2015 6.22pm
Cameron's point scoring and constant emphasis on the economy may become a little tiring and the Tories may have to rethink their leadership soon enough. May make Corbyn seem like a political genius and genuine reformer whilst revealing the Tories as the 'crab people' they really are. What a lot of hogwash.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
-TUX- Alphabettispaghetti 16 Sep 15 6.46pm | |
---|---|
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 6.28pm
Quote -TUX- at 16 Sep 2015 6.17pm
I kinda figured, what with you being such an avid campaigner and all that, you'd welcome the views of the electorate being aired. I've not complained about the views of the electorate being aired.But 6 questions hardly reflect the public mood ! I would far rather Paxman ask the PM and really 'grill' him on his answers.Not "Comrade Corbyn" with his form of extreme socialism who just asks questions and never "drills down" into the reply.All very bland and soporific.
You look forward to PMQ's purely for the 'theatrical element'.
Time to move forward together. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
OldFella London 16 Sep 15 6.51pm | |
---|---|
Quote nickgusset at 16 Sep 2015 5.55pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.43pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.31pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.27pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.22pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.14pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 16 Sep 2015 5.04pm
I think you have to say that Corbyn came over far better today than Milliband ever did. Corbyn never came back with anything after Cameron provided answers.It wasn't a "Yah Boo" cut and thrust session. Let's get back to the "Punch and Judy" show instead of a bland question and answer session ! Edited by Willo (16 Sep 2015 5.16pm)
I really don't agree that cut and thrust sessions between political leaders is responsible for any political malaise.Think the issues are far more complex and run deeper than that. Today's PMQs was bland and boring and the 'House' was as dead as a mortuary.Hopefully this won't last.
I like to see Prime Minister's challenged on their answers and this brings about a "Cut and thrust". All Corbyn did was ask questions and meekly accept what Cameron had to say.He came back with nothing.It was the interaction between the party leaders which really made PMQs. It was not what you call "Playground verbals" but lively debate. Maybe PMQ's should be a list of questions given to the PM on a sheet of paper and he runs down them providing answers !!!! Or maybe he should sit in a "Mastermind" chair and a quiz master appointed to ask questions !
The earth just moved. A sensible comment from NG.
Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it.. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 16 Sep 15 6.59pm | |
---|---|
Quote OldFella at 16 Sep 2015 6.51pm
Quote nickgusset at 16 Sep 2015 5.55pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.43pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.31pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.27pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.22pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.14pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 16 Sep 2015 5.04pm
I think you have to say that Corbyn came over far better today than Milliband ever did. Corbyn never came back with anything after Cameron provided answers.It wasn't a "Yah Boo" cut and thrust session. Let's get back to the "Punch and Judy" show instead of a bland question and answer session ! Edited by Willo (16 Sep 2015 5.16pm)
I really don't agree that cut and thrust sessions between political leaders is responsible for any political malaise.Think the issues are far more complex and run deeper than that. Today's PMQs was bland and boring and the 'House' was as dead as a mortuary.Hopefully this won't last.
I like to see Prime Minister's challenged on their answers and this brings about a "Cut and thrust". All Corbyn did was ask questions and meekly accept what Cameron had to say.He came back with nothing.It was the interaction between the party leaders which really made PMQs. It was not what you call "Playground verbals" but lively debate. Maybe PMQ's should be a list of questions given to the PM on a sheet of paper and he runs down them providing answers !!!! Or maybe he should sit in a "Mastermind" chair and a quiz master appointed to ask questions !
The earth just moved. A sensible comment from NG.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
OldFella London 16 Sep 15 7.06pm | |
---|---|
Quote nickgusset at 16 Sep 2015 6.59pm
Quote OldFella at 16 Sep 2015 6.51pm
Quote nickgusset at 16 Sep 2015 5.55pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.43pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.31pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.27pm
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.22pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 5.14pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 16 Sep 2015 5.04pm
I think you have to say that Corbyn came over far better today than Milliband ever did. Corbyn never came back with anything after Cameron provided answers.It wasn't a "Yah Boo" cut and thrust session. Let's get back to the "Punch and Judy" show instead of a bland question and answer session ! Edited by Willo (16 Sep 2015 5.16pm)
I really don't agree that cut and thrust sessions between political leaders is responsible for any political malaise.Think the issues are far more complex and run deeper than that. Today's PMQs was bland and boring and the 'House' was as dead as a mortuary.Hopefully this won't last.
I like to see Prime Minister's challenged on their answers and this brings about a "Cut and thrust". All Corbyn did was ask questions and meekly accept what Cameron had to say.He came back with nothing.It was the interaction between the party leaders which really made PMQs. It was not what you call "Playground verbals" but lively debate. Maybe PMQ's should be a list of questions given to the PM on a sheet of paper and he runs down them providing answers !!!! Or maybe he should sit in a "Mastermind" chair and a quiz master appointed to ask questions !
The earth just moved. A sensible comment from NG.
For sure. I have had many thousands of letters from all over the country asking me to put questions to any lefties I know, and thought in the new spirit of open democracy introduced by Comrade Corbyn that the HOL would be as good a place as any to start
Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it.. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 15 7.11pm | |
---|---|
Quote -TUX- at 16 Sep 2015 6.46pm
Quote Willo at 16 Sep 2015 6.28pm
Quote -TUX- at 16 Sep 2015 6.17pm
I kinda figured, what with you being such an avid campaigner and all that, you'd welcome the views of the electorate being aired. I've not complained about the views of the electorate being aired.But 6 questions hardly reflect the public mood ! I would far rather Paxman ask the PM and really 'grill' him on his answers.Not "Comrade Corbyn" with his form of extreme socialism who just asks questions and never "drills down" into the reply.All very bland and soporific.
You look forward to PMQ's purely for the 'theatrical element'.
No, I look forward to PMQs for the cut and thrust of lively debate triggered by questions to the PM.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hrolf The Ganger 16 Sep 15 7.16pm | |
---|---|
Quote Kermit8 at 16 Sep 2015 5.20pm
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 16 Sep 2015 4.56pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Sep 2015 3.21pm
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 16 Sep 2015 2.35pm
I see some of the usual left wing chaps on here already in the denial stage. Corbyn can ask all he likes at question time but his face doesn't fit the 21st century. Sorry to be so cynical and broad stroke about it but that is the reality. Doesn't matter really if his 'face fits' or not, or if people who'd never vote for him don't like him, the reason he is there is on the basis of a democratic mandate of the Labour party, by an approved process. What disturbs me most are 'Labour Party Parliamentary members' who seem to think they're more important than the people who vote for them. It won't be Corbyn that sinks the party, it'll be members of the party throwing hissy fits because their own membership voted for someone they didn't want. It'll like be the who 'Euro' schism of the Tory party that f**ked their own party in the 90s and early 21st century.
However, I do actually believe that his face does matter. People who vote for personality and floating voters in general will not vote for this man. If Milliband was a liability for Labour then Corbyn will be like the Anti Christ.
Corbyn operates on a different and higher, albeit more left wijavascripttylebut(0);ng, level. He will, i think, command a slightly begrudging respect from elements in all the parties and some of their voters. Something Ed was not able to achieve even from just within his own. Perhaps, but the electorate will not vote for it. I admired Tony Benn but I would never vote for him or Robin Cook or Michael Foot or any other left wing idealistic politician. You will see.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
kingdowieonthewall Sussex, ex-Cronx. 16 Sep 15 7.17pm | |
---|---|
Corbyn reminds me of a harmless old metal work teacher I used to suffer the odd hours tedium with at school.
Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents? |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.