Islam Slimani (papertalk)

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Islam Slimani (papertalk)

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

Indefatigable South London 27 Nov 15 5.48pm
To highlight my point, Dame D'Doyle scored 5 in 15 for Hull and 6 in 26 for Senegal against the same teams Slimani scored his international goals. 27 in 66 for Lokomotiv Moscow. Ok Hull only paid like 3 or 4 million for him, but Slimani's goal scoring stats are better, he's younger and he plays in a better league.
Alert a moderator to this post

Indefatigable

South London 27 Nov 15 5.48pm

To highlight my point, Dame D'Doyle scored 5 in 15 for Hull and 6 in 26 for Senegal against the same teams Slimani scored his international goals. 27 in 66 for Lokomotiv Moscow.

Ok Hull only paid like 3 or 4 million for him, but Slimani's goal scoring stats are better, he's younger and he plays in a better league.

Alert a moderator to this post

Petereagle Brockley 28 Nov 15 10.00am
Quote Indefatigable at 26 Nov 2015 4.56pm Another view by an Algerian journalist this time. This one almost completely different suggesting what he offers defensive, aerially, physically and in holding the ball up skill almost makes him sound Palace Perfect. [Link] [Link] Some useful stats. Most worrying is that he seems to lack pace and only average at linking play. But scores highly on power and strength, and a pretty good finisher
Alert a moderator to this post

Petereagle

Brockley 28 Nov 15 10.00am

Quote Indefatigable at 26 Nov 2015 4.56pm

Another view by an Algerian journalist this time. This one almost completely different suggesting what he offers defensive, aerially, physically and in holding the ball up skill almost makes him sound Palace Perfect.

[Link]

Some useful stats. Most worrying is that he seems to lack pace and only average at linking play. But scores highly on power and strength, and a pretty good finisher

Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85 Sydney 30 Nov 15 4.22am
Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough
Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85

Sydney 30 Nov 15 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment.

Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered.

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough

Alert a moderator to this post

Catfish Burgess Hill 01 Dec 15 7.06am
Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
Alert a moderator to this post

Catfish

Burgess Hill 01 Dec 15 7.06am

Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m

Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Alert a moderator to this post

djmobi Oxford 01 Dec 15 10.01am
Quote Catfish at 01 Dec 2015 7.06am Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m Exactly right.....any player who is scoring at the rate Slimani is in a so called "competitive league" will be too much money for us. I think it makes perfect sense to send your scouts to the guys doing it in lesser leagues and then decide if you want to take a punt of if they can replicate it at Premier League level. Transfers for the last few years across all premier league teams and a quick look at the top goal scorer list for this season is proof that it doesn't matter where you were scoring your goals last season.
Alert a moderator to this post

djmobi

Oxford 01 Dec 15 10.01am

Quote Catfish at 01 Dec 2015 7.06am

Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m

Exactly right.....any player who is scoring at the rate Slimani is in a so called "competitive league" will be too much money for us.

I think it makes perfect sense to send your scouts to the guys doing it in lesser leagues and then decide if you want to take a punt of if they can replicate it at Premier League level.

Transfers for the last few years across all premier league teams and a quick look at the top goal scorer list for this season is proof that it doesn't matter where you were scoring your goals last season.

Alert a moderator to this post

Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 01 Dec 15 10.31am
Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough Stop talking sense Rob! "We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
Alert a moderator to this post

Brentmiester_General

Front line in the battle against t... 01 Dec 15 10.31am

Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

Stop talking sense Rob!

"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Alert a moderator to this post

Andy_G Wimbledon 01 Dec 15 11.18am
Quote Catfish at 01 Dec 2015 7.06am Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m Spot on. We have to take a punt on these type of players before they become established and are out of range. The Bony, Benteke types were punts that worked but of course there are the ones that don't worked and are expensive mistakes, that's the gamble. No idea really on this guy and likely to be the same for any foreign target, trust the scouting. The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years
Alert a moderator to this post

Andy_G

Wimbledon 01 Dec 15 11.18am

Quote Catfish at 01 Dec 2015 7.06am

Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

The less money you have the more of a punt you have to take. You could wait until he is a confirmed, undisputed superstar but then his price will be 30m

Spot on. We have to take a punt on these type of players before they become established and are out of range. The Bony, Benteke types were punts that worked but of course there are the ones that don't worked and are expensive mistakes, that's the gamble. No idea really on this guy and likely to be the same for any foreign target, trust the scouting.

The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85 Sydney 01 Dec 15 10.39pm
Quote Brentmiester_General at 01 Dec 2015 10.31am Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot. for years & years weve watched from afar seeing mid-table PL clubs throw their magic beans at expensive players from inferior league in the hope they will turn out to be a star in the faster, more physical, more demanding PL. There are countless examples of strikers coming in from afar for somewhere in the region of £10+ only to be a dissapointment. Now its palace looking at spending this type of money on this type of player it makes me feel unesasy. You can point out his internation record of a goal every other gaem, well take a look at who those goals were scored against. [Link] 99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams. Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who? you could point out we have already started spending big money on players like wickham/cabaye/dann(wages). but we already knew what those players can do, they were tried & tested in this league and to a certain extent were "no brainers" when it came to the deals we offered. I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really. There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience. The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU. Why would you write the player off? There are more teams than just us looking at him. Wilfried Bony was signed from Ducth football, Michu was playing in the second tier in Spain for most of his career and had one season in La Liga for Rayo Vallecano. Yes Slimani isnt in the most competitive league but niehter was Henrik Larsson and he went from Celtic to Man Utd to Barca, if they are good enough then they are good enough Stop talking sense Rob! Apologies Luke, I promise it wont happen again :-)
Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85

Sydney 01 Dec 15 10.39pm

Quote Brentmiester_General at 01 Dec 2015 10.31am

Quote seltz85 at 30 Nov 2015 4.22am

Quote braunstoneagle at 27 Nov 2015 9.13am

How times have changed in recent years and how it feels weird with the shoe being on the other foot.

[Link]

99% of them against bumphuk nowhere teams.

Yes he has scored goals in portugal but again, against who?

I admit ive only seen slimani play a few games, and he looks ok, but £15 ok? nah not really.

There must be a striker in england/spain/italy/germany who would cost similar to slimani but already have big league experience.

The thought of us taking a punt at that price, on that player makes me feel quite uneasy. I would rather we signed andy carroll from WHU.

Stop talking sense Rob!

Apologies Luke, I promise it wont happen again :-)

Alert a moderator to this post

braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 04 Dec 15 5.28pm
To those who replied to m post..thanks, decent constructive debate is always good. At no point have I written off slimani as a player, just pointed out how times change and how uneasy I feel with us taking a 15m gamble. Its all opinions but a club like palace you expect results for £15m. A gamble to me is what whu paid for sakho in 4.7m, or villa paid 7m for benteke, or indeed ourselves with roughly 4/5m on gayle. We paid £12 for cabaye...that wasn't a gamble, we knew we were getting quality. I want to see us punch with the other teams our size, I just hope we don't end up with a van wolfswinkle or brown ideye. ‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
Alert a moderator to this post

braunstoneagle

the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 04 Dec 15 5.28pm

Send a Private Message to braunstoneagle

To those who replied to m post..thanks, decent constructive debate is always good.

At no point have I written off slimani as a player, just pointed out how times change and how uneasy I feel with us taking a 15m gamble.

Its all opinions but a club like palace you expect results for £15m.

A gamble to me is what whu paid for sakho in 4.7m, or villa paid 7m for benteke, or indeed ourselves with roughly 4/5m on gayle.

We paid £12 for cabaye...that wasn't a gamble, we knew we were getting quality.

I want to see us punch with the other teams our size, I just hope we don't end up with a van wolfswinkle or brown ideye.

‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway

Alert a moderator to this post

wonder Madrid 05 Dec 15 3.26pm
I know quite a few sporting fans here in lisbon and they seem to think he's built for the prem.
Alert a moderator to this post

wonder

Madrid 05 Dec 15 3.26pm

I know quite a few sporting fans here in lisbon and they seem to think he's built for the prem.

Alert a moderator to this post

Brisbane Eagle Brisbane 05 Dec 15 3.29pm
Dead cert. Get him in up front.
Alert a moderator to this post

Brisbane Eagle

Brisbane 05 Dec 15 3.29pm

Send a Private Message to Brisbane Eagle

Dead cert. Get him in up front.

Alert a moderator to this post

wonder Madrid 05 Dec 15 4.27pm
Portuguese teams tend to do very well in europe considering they only have 3 big clubs. Right now benfica and porto have very good teams yet sporting are leading the league. This season slimani's put away 11 in 17.
Alert a moderator to this post

wonder

Madrid 05 Dec 15 4.27pm

Portuguese teams tend to do very well in europe considering they only have 3 big clubs. Right now benfica and porto have very good teams yet sporting are leading the league.

This season slimani's put away 11 in 17.

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Islam Slimani (papertalk)

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors