This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Wisbech Eagle Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 24 8.41am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Matov
Its a not unreasonable observation although I suspect the numbers are closer than you think. For me, Brexit became increasingly important AFTER the referendum was won because of the concerted effort to have my vote rendered null and void with the large-scale abuse heaped upon people who voted to leave Let's not forget the ferocity of the Remain camp afterwards with even her Majestys Opposition actively promoting a second referendum in the run-up to our departure. Given what I still see as the massive institutional resistance to making Brexit a success then yes, I still see it as something that matters because of the damage it did to the confidence that many people had in our system. We left the EU in the end but after far, far more of a struggle than it should have been once the result from June 23rd 2016 was known. And this fissure in British society remains. Probably always will do. What you continue to fail to recognise is that it’s Parliament that is sovereign and not a referendum. Parliament wasn’t bound by a referendum result, especially one that close, and with everything that emerged subsequent to it being held had a duty to debate and consider the way forward. I thought they should have rejected it completely in those circumstances but going back to the people to confirm they still wanted to proceed was the least they should have done. That they didn’t was the biggest failure of parliamentary democracy in the UK in my lifetime. A failure that has rebounded on us all and will haunt generations to come.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hrolf The Ganger 12 Jun 24 8.55am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Yes it is. It was out of date the moment Article 50 was triggered. From that moment on the battle lines changed from stopping us being stupid and leaving to repairing the damage and getting us back in. So you didn't accept the result. Thanks for clarifying.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hrolf The Ganger 12 Jun 24 8.56am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What you continue to fail to recognise is that it’s Parliament that is sovereign and not a referendum. Parliament wasn’t bound by a referendum result, especially one that close, and with everything that emerged subsequent to it being held had a duty to debate and consider the way forward. I thought they should have rejected it completely in those circumstances but going back to the people to confirm they still wanted to proceed was the least they should have done. That they didn’t was the biggest failure of parliamentary democracy in the UK in my lifetime. A failure that has rebounded on us all and will haunt generations to come. What you fail to recognise is that no one is interested in your pathetic excuses for being a poor loser.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Behind Enemy Lines Sussex 12 Jun 24 9.05am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What you continue to fail to recognise is that it’s Parliament that is sovereign and not a referendum. Parliament wasn’t bound by a referendum result, especially one that close, and with everything that emerged subsequent to it being held had a duty to debate and consider the way forward. I thought they should have rejected it completely in those circumstances but going back to the people to confirm they still wanted to proceed was the least they should have done. That they didn’t was the biggest failure of parliamentary democracy in the UK in my lifetime. A failure that has rebounded on us all and will haunt generations to come. Perhaps if Parliament had given the public a say during the 4 decades that the ‘EU’ had morphed from a mere trading block of western countries into a over large political giant, then perhaps a referendum would not have been needed. It’s of their own making and so is the eventual result. Live with it and make the most of it.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Spiderman Horsham 12 Jun 24 9.16am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
The Lib Dems manifesto is comfortably left of anything Labour are proposing - I think they will do reasonably well. God help us!:
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Spiderman Horsham 12 Jun 24 9.18am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Because it's true, yes. The fact you still think people haven't 'accepted the referendum' is just hilarious - it's a slogan about 4 years out of date. Read the Brexit thread on bbs. Not only have many not accepted it, some even wish early death on those that voted leave. Nice lot us Palace fans! Edited by Spiderman (12 Jun 2024 9.19am)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
silvertop Portishead 12 Jun 24 9.33am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's quite possible that the Tory Remainer left are throwing this election and will be happy to see Labour move us back towards Europe. Such is their quasi religious obsession with the EU and their strings worked by their elite puppet masters. It would be very good for this country if the Tory Right and Reform joined forces and ended this ridiculous situation. A very large proportion of this country needs better representation. We cannot continue as we are. I think this conspiracy is groundless. The Tory right have mismanaged since 2019 to such an extent that they don't need anyone's help to lose. And I know this tends to draw direct attacks from people on here when posters who are not aligned to their political view say this sort of thing. However, take a step back and assess the recent history. How can you safely arrive at an alternative opinion? They have been so bad that even blue rinsers from the Shires would rather vote Labour than tolerate them for another day. The break up of the Tory party is a real risk. And your last line is equally hard to argue against. I have and will always vote. I have little respect for those who do not... and then complain. But who gets my vote??? Right now I am sorely tempted to put a cross against the Portishead Bring Back the Fishmonger Party (or like) as the other options are all unpalatable albeit in different ways.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hrolf The Ganger 12 Jun 24 9.47am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by silvertop
I think this conspiracy is groundless. The Tory right have mismanaged since 2019 to such an extent that they don't need anyone's help to lose. And I know this tends to draw direct attacks from people on here when posters who are not aligned to their political view say this sort of thing. However, take a step back and assess the recent history. How can you safely arrive at an alternative opinion? They have been so bad that even blue rinsers from the Shires would rather vote Labour than tolerate them for another day. The break up of the Tory party is a real risk. And your last line is equally hard to argue against. I have and will always vote. I have little respect for those who do not... and then complain. But who gets my vote??? Right now I am sorely tempted to put a cross against the Portishead Bring Back the Fishmonger Party (or like) as the other options are all unpalatable albeit in different ways. I wouldn't be certain of anything these days. You can see the obsessive nature of Remainers on this site and more so on the other one. The Tory left are bitter and out for revenge. They got Johnson and that was obviously going to hamper their chances of winning an election. They humiliated Liz Truss. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (12 Jun 2024 9.48am)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
silvertop Portishead 12 Jun 24 10.04am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I regard this as rather an insulting paragraph Silver, it's unfortunate that you wrote it. Much of what you've stated here is based on your own assumptions that support a war that took well over thirty million lives, possibly forty. This counterfactual didn't come from a Reform spokesman. It's been aired by many intelligent and indeed famous people. Without enlargement the half a million we lost in that war would have lived....Instead their graves were made certain.....So when you insult people like me perhaps you should reflect upon the hubris that assumes there was no better option. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Jun 2024 2.57pm) There is a great deal to unpick there, but I will just leave the final paragraph. Reform are a single issue party who are tapping in to the fear of a loss of culture and identity. That is not an unfounded fear or one just held by those who are dim or racist. E.g. I see and feel it too, and I am supposed to be the woolly left. The problem is caused by non-European immigration. There needs to be much better control. But the flow has gone unchecked for decades despite successive governments chucking cash and ideas at it. Thus, you either divert vast resources at a considerable opportunity cost and/or breach international law with impunity. All of which is likely to leave the country poorer, in turmoil, and with the issue largely untouched. I am afraid that we are at a point where the best we can get is a marginally more efficient control at the frontier and better management within. My issue is two fold. Reform are promising what is effectively an ethnic defence. This is something I genuinely believe they are not capable of delivering; and after they get their hands on the treasury and the economy tanks, they will be even less resourced and capable. The other problem I have is that there is too much actual fascist in Reform. Populist, nationalist, and worryingly averse to accountability. I don't see them denying minorities property rights or cancelling any further elections etc. They are Fascist Lite. But what they say is far too close to what was said. And it concerns me that the generation who experienced are gone and their descendants have already forgotten the hard lesson their parents learned. Thus, I still think that if one of our Tommies who liberated Belsen was to learn that his own children were voting Reform, they would turn in their grave. What else would he do?
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Hrolf The Ganger 12 Jun 24 10.53am | |
---|---|
Originally posted by silvertop
There is a great deal to unpick there, but I will just leave the final paragraph. Reform are a single issue party who are tapping in to the fear of a loss of culture and identity. That is not an unfounded fear or one just held by those who are dim or racist. E.g. I see and feel it too, and I am supposed to be the woolly left. The problem is caused by non-European immigration. There needs to be much better control. But the flow has gone unchecked for decades despite successive governments chucking cash and ideas at it. Thus, you either divert vast resources at a considerable opportunity cost and/or breach international law with impunity. All of which is likely to leave the country poorer, in turmoil, and with the issue largely untouched. I am afraid that we are at a point where the best we can get is a marginally more efficient control at the frontier and better management within. My issue is two fold. Reform are promising what is effectively an ethnic defence. This is something I genuinely believe they are not capable of delivering; and after they get their hands on the treasury and the economy tanks, they will be even less resourced and capable. The other problem I have is that there is too much actual fascist in Reform. Populist, nationalist, and worryingly averse to accountability. I don't see them denying minorities property rights or cancelling any further elections etc. They are Fascist Lite. But what they say is far too close to what was said. And it concerns me that the generation who experienced are gone and their descendants have already forgotten the hard lesson their parents learned. Thus, I still think that if one of our Tommies who liberated Belsen was to learn that his own children were voting Reform, they would turn in their grave. What else would he do? If we didn't have mass immigration causing vastly increased crime, terrorism, social disharmony and cultural destruction, we would have no Reform party. When you treat the poplulation with such contempt for so long, you eventually get a reaction.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
silvertop Portishead 12 Jun 24 12.10pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I wouldn't be certain of anything these days. You can see the obsessive nature of Remainers on this site and more so on the other one. The Tory left are bitter and out for revenge. They got Johnson and that was obviously going to hamper their chances of winning an election. They humiliated Liz Truss. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (12 Jun 2024 9.48am) This is why I said you need to stand well back and look again. These points are never well received on here but politicians on either end of the spectrum are always of the lowest stock. That would be either those who hold your view, or those who hold Steeleye's. They couldn't run a whelk store. Our experience of decades of socialism and now the last 5 years seems to bear that out. If the left of the Tories were that strong and Machiavellian, they would have controlled a charismatic vote-magnet like BJ and steered him to a post Brexit world in their image. However, your memory must be playing tricks. He was actually sacked for lying (badly) to Parliament. Even a disingenuous, self-serving rogue like him knew he had to fall on the sword. And Truss! Where does one start? I think the Greens or Reform would have to take power for us to witness a level of economic ineptitude to match hers. No, I suspect it was the City that funds the Party that saw her out. They were not going to stand for the shocks and uncertainty that her leadership would continue to deliver, as entertaining as they were for the outside world to watch. The explanation is a simple one. It is neither your conspiracy, nor globalism, nor the desire for a Remainer utopia. It is being booted out for being really cr@p. No need to over-think it.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
silvertop Portishead 12 Jun 24 12.17pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If we didn't have mass immigration causing vastly increased crime, terrorism, social disharmony and cultural destruction, we would have no Reform party. When you treat the poplulation with such contempt for so long, you eventually get a reaction. I get the problem and I get the rise of Reform. The problem is, they will not solve the problem. They will merely gain traction by saying they will. If anything, I fear they will make it worse. And then, who will you turn to?
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.