This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
kav The Helicopter View 19 Dec 03 11.14am | |
---|---|
Facts are(for whatever reasons)she lied more than once.Punishment follows.The lenght of sentence was imo lighter than it could/should`ve been. Personaly,I think she`s a lot cuter than you`re giving her credit for. Quote Bexter at 19 Dec 2003 10:44am
so you think all that time in custody being bullied by other inmates wasn't punishment? the fact that she will never be able to lead a normal life, the fact that she still has time to serve.... i don't think that's lightly imo...
Everytime I get high I lay my head on my baby's breasts |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
kav The Helicopter View 19 Dec 03 11.16am | |
---|---|
Not a fraction of the sentence of the two girls families.As for the girls themselves,God rest their souls. Quote alexh_17 at 19 Dec 2003 10:56am
Not wanting to continue this, but perhaps the Judge took into account that when Carr finishes her sentence, chances are she is not going to be accepted back into society with open arms. She will be punished for the rest of her life, as will Huntley. Two young girls have been murdered, and the sick individual responsible is behind bars. The woman who tried to protect him, rightly or wrongly, is now behind bars. Though she may have a lenient sentence, she is still going to be 'serving' another for the rest of her life.
Everytime I get high I lay my head on my baby's breasts |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
alexh_17 The Site of The Worlds Biggest Pil... 19 Dec 03 12.52pm | |
---|---|
Quote kav at 19 Dec 2003 11:16am
Not a fraction of the sentence of the two girls families.As for the girls themselves,God rest their souls. Quote alexh_17 at 19 Dec 2003 10:56am
Not wanting to continue this, but perhaps the Judge took into account that when Carr finishes her sentence, chances are she is not going to be accepted back into society with open arms. She will be punished for the rest of her life, as will Huntley. Two young girls have been murdered, and the sick individual responsible is behind bars. The woman who tried to protect him, rightly or wrongly, is now behind bars. Though she may have a lenient sentence, she is still going to be 'serving' another for the rest of her life.
Head Honcho of the CPFC Pillow Fighting Force |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
james_cpfc Outside London 19 Dec 03 1.13pm | |
---|---|
Quote kav at 19 Dec 2003 11:14am
Facts are(for whatever reasons)she lied more than once.Punishment follows.The lenght of sentence was imo lighter than it could/should`ve been. Personaly,I think she`s a lot cuter than you`re giving her credit for. Quote Bexter at 19 Dec 2003 10:44am
so you think all that time in custody being bullied by other inmates wasn't punishment? the fact that she will never be able to lead a normal life, the fact that she still has time to serve.... i don't think that's lightly imo... You should be locked up......
Make yourself busy or I'll cut your face off |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
kav The Helicopter View 19 Dec 03 2.37pm | |
---|---|
Bollox mate.I`m entitled to my opinion and that`s my take on it. Can you truly say in your heart of hearts that it`s not possible she is a bit smarter than she pretends? Maybe I should`ve said"smarter" instead of "cuter",is that what griped you?I didn`t mean cute in the traditional sense - must be the Irish coming out in me.
Everytime I get high I lay my head on my baby's breasts |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
jcreedy 19 Dec 03 2.39pm | |
---|---|
I thought that Kav Maybe now she's single we can find a HOL man to send her letters in the slammer!
It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else. - John Bostock (Nov 2007) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
james_cpfc Outside London 19 Dec 03 3.25pm | |
---|---|
Quote kav at 19 Dec 2003 2:37pm
Bollox mate.I`m entitled to my opinion and that`s my take on it. Can you truly say in your heart of hearts that it`s not possible she is a bit smarter than she pretends? Maybe I should`ve said"smarter" instead of "cuter",is that what griped you?I didn`t mean cute in the traditional sense - must be the Irish coming out in me.
By the way, she isnt as timid as it may seem. She bottled someone once. Sound like the niave ol' Maxxy babes we thought she was?
Make yourself busy or I'll cut your face off |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Lombardoli Brockham 19 Dec 03 3.42pm | |
---|---|
Quote Bexter at 19 Dec 2003 10:28am
good job you weren't in the jury eh? hanged or banged up for life for giving an alibi to a loved one, whether it was blind love or fear..... ?! Surely love cannot be used as an excuse! She should not be rewarded for ignorance anyway! Not that I believe she is innocent or stupid enough to be ignorant of his crimes.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Petealiator 1066 Country! 19 Dec 03 4.16pm | |
---|---|
Quote alexh_17 at 19 Dec 2003 12:54am
The first I've heard of this, but if thats true - surely a reason to provide him with an alibi, i.e. FEAR? I'm also glad you know more than any of the jurors who heard every detail the Courts deemed relevant to the case. And I would agree with Bexter, perhaps not truly believing he was innocent so much as loving him to an extent that she would not accept he was guilty?
What part of "SHE KNEW WHAT HE WAS CAPABLE OF, KNEW ALL ABOUT HIS PAST" do you people not understand? What part of "HUNTLEY RAPED CARR, SO SHE KNEW WHAT HE WAS" do you people not understand? What part of "CARR GAVE HUNTLEY A FALSE ALIBI AGAINST A RAPE CHARGE" do you people not understand? What part of "SHE KNEW DAMN WELL WHAT HUNTLEY HAD DONE BUT STILL COVERED FOR HIM" do you people not understand? That bitch could have prevented this, she chose not to. If she was so terrified of Huntley, why did she come rushing back from Grimsby to give him an alibi and get him bailed when he was safely behind bars? Fear? Bollocks! Wake up! I must admit; the death penalty probably is an easy way out for the b******s, that much I do agree with Bexter about, it's a bit of a knee-jerk reaction, but I'd sure feel a lot better if life meant life, and that life meant a life of seriously 'Hard Labour'. These b******s should be forced to do back-breaking graft for the remainder of their sorry piece of s*** lives, not left to lay around twiddling their thumbs all day! Bexter me old sparring partner of old, I believe wholeheartedly in love - I've loved my wife (more than life itself) since the night we met some sixteen years ago, without her, I'd be lost, I love her more with every passing day -but I don't - I won't! - believe in 'unconditional love', my belief in moral decency demands it. The decree which I live by, above all in my life, is; 'Good over evil', it's simple and idealistic but if there's anything in this s***, filth-ridden world worth taking up arms and fighting for; it's good over evil, and that decree demands that I have no choice but to dismiss 'unconditional love' as an incredibly selfish and morally devoid concept. If I discovered my wife was a monster, she would then; not be the woman I thought she was; the woman I love, and so my love would die. Some of you see a woman whose only crime is lying to save the skin of the man she loved. I believe you are very wrong and very naive indeed, and so do the jury of the case in question, they found her GUILTY. Some of us see an absolute monster that knew exactly what Huntley was and what he was into, knew what he was capable of, knew what he had done, and chose to help him anyway!
My Rocksteady band... |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Bexter By the Sea 19 Dec 03 4.58pm | |
---|---|
firstly, don't believe all you read in the media - surely everyone knows that? they are loving sensationalising this story and that in itself is gross. how do you know that she knew he had done it? and what's her previous - anything that says she would help a murderer of small children? and even if he did rape her - which i have never read or heard about, then why should she assume he would also be capable of killing kids? unfortunately rape is very common within relationships, and fortunately child murder fairly rare.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Petealiator 1066 Country! 20 Dec 03 10.23am | |
---|---|
Bexter, why is it when you're confronted with a strong argument, you always resort to your well worn statement "don't believe everything you read in the papers" chestnut? Can't you for once respond with a valid argument in the face of such damning evidence? If a girl who was Carr's best friend says Huntley raped Carr, I'm gonna give that girl the benefit of the doubt, because she was there, so she probably knows more than you do! If a bloke says he had a fight with Huntley and knocked him out for beating the s*** out of Carr in public, I'm gonna give him the benefit of the doubt, because he was there, you weren't! If a girl comes forward and tells her story of how she was brutally raped by Huntley, so badly she can't have children because of the internal damage inflicted, I'm gonna give her the benefit of the doubt, coz she was there, you weren't! Carr knew ALL of this! Carr knew Huntley had raped on more than one occasion. Together they defrauded a charity.
My Rocksteady band... |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Sherlock Virginia, Confederate States of Am... 20 Dec 03 11.09am | |
---|---|
The bottom line is that she KNEW she was lying wether she believed that Huntley had murdered the girls or not.In doing so she was putting other children at risk from Huntley while the police were exploring alternative avenues.Should someone get a lighter sentence because they may have low self-esteem or been anorexic in the past?What a nonsense!To be incarcerated is`nt nice but then Maxine Carr did have the choice to not put herself in that position.Let`s just remember that the most important people in this case are those two little girls who have no choices at all any more and their parents who are now serving a life sentence of their own.
The famous Alan Mullery went to Rome to SIGN the Pope. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.