This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Pete53 Hassocks 13 Nov 19 12.13pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by punksnotdead
Overrated Liam Gallagher , Paul Weller, The Beatles Underrated The Ruts, The Selector, The Damned Sorry but I can never let it pass when some says the Beatles were overrated. I am not saying everyone need has to necessarily like their music ( although I find it strange, considering their huge output, that anyone could not cannot find some stuff they like) but to say they are overrated is to completely overlook what they did and the effect they had on popular music. When the Beatles arrived in January 1963 with Please Please Me they had a monumental impact on the music scene and paved the way for all the other "beat groups"that followed. Prior to 1963 the charts were pretty anodyne with ballads, watered down rock & roll, novelty records and instrumentals. Prior to the Beatles the group concept, something we take for granted now, of performers playing instruments and singing hardly existed. The emergence of The Beatles was like a bright light being switched on after the dull and turgid state popular music had descended into . They looked different, their sound was fresh and immediately engaging, they wrote their own music ( at least their singles), and turned the whole music scene upside down. Many existing artists suddenly found themselves redundant with their musical style rendered out dated at a stroke. One of the most impressive things about them was that they never became complacent. They were innovators always leading the way be it in their song writing, imaginative use of instrumentation, lyrics, album cover design, playing live in stadiums, and much more. Perhaps it would be stretching it to say that music today wouldn't be what it is without The Beatles, but they provided the springboard for what followed and opened up new horizons for fellow artists. Okay, so their early releases likes of She Loves You may sound a bit simplistic now, but you have place what they did in the context of the period - 1963 ( and indeed 1970 when they split) were very different times from 2019. I rest my case m'lud. ps I do agree with you regards Paul Weller
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stirlingsays 13 Nov 19 12.14pm | |
---|---|
The most criminally underated band I ever came across was: David Devant and his spirit wife. I still regularly play some of their stuff....my favourite being their 'Dolphin Square'....I'll do a cover of it one day.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
djcpfc Within a 5 minute walk 13 Nov 19 12.14pm | |
---|---|
Overrated Suede Dogs**+* sold millions of records to people who haven’t listen to them in the last 5 years. Underrated Stiff Little Fingers Amazing music that seldom gets heard.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 13 Nov 19 1.01pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Pete53
Sorry but I can never let it pass when some says the Beatles were overrated. I am not saying everyone need has to necessarily like their music ( although I find it strange, considering their huge output, that anyone could not cannot find some stuff they like) but to say they are overrated is to completely overlook what they did and the effect they had on popular music. When the Beatles arrived in January 1963 with Please Please Me they had a monumental impact on the music scene and paved the way for all the other "beat groups"that followed. Prior to 1963 the charts were pretty anodyne with ballads, watered down rock & roll, novelty records and instrumentals. Prior to the Beatles the group concept, something we take for granted now, of performers playing instruments and singing hardly existed. The emergence of The Beatles was like a bright light being switched on after the dull and turgid state popular music had descended into . They looked different, their sound was fresh and immediately engaging, they wrote their own music ( at least their singles), and turned the whole music scene upside down. Many existing artists suddenly found themselves redundant with their musical style rendered out dated at a stroke. One of the most impressive things about them was that they never became complacent. They were innovators always leading the way be it in their song writing, imaginative use of instrumentation, lyrics, album cover design, playing live in stadiums, and much more. Perhaps it would be stretching it to say that music today wouldn't be what it is without The Beatles, but they provided the springboard for what followed and opened up new horizons for fellow artists. Okay, so their early releases likes of She Loves You may sound a bit simplistic now, but you have place what they did in the context of the period - 1963 ( and indeed 1970 when they split) were very different times from 2019. I rest my case m'lud. ps I do agree with you regards Paul Weller I would argue that The Beatles were in fact underrated.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Badger11 Beckenham 13 Nov 19 1.12pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Pete53
Sorry but I can never let it pass when some says the Beatles were overrated. I am not saying everyone need has to necessarily like their music ( although I find it strange, considering their huge output, that anyone could not cannot find some stuff they like) but to say they are overrated is to completely overlook what they did and the effect they had on popular music. When the Beatles arrived in January 1963 with Please Please Me they had a monumental impact on the music scene and paved the way for all the other "beat groups"that followed. Prior to 1963 the charts were pretty anodyne with ballads, watered down rock & roll, novelty records and instrumentals. Prior to the Beatles the group concept, something we take for granted now, of performers playing instruments and singing hardly existed. The emergence of The Beatles was like a bright light being switched on after the dull and turgid state popular music had descended into . They looked different, their sound was fresh and immediately engaging, they wrote their own music ( at least their singles), and turned the whole music scene upside down. Many existing artists suddenly found themselves redundant with their musical style rendered out dated at a stroke. One of the most impressive things about them was that they never became complacent. They were innovators always leading the way be it in their song writing, imaginative use of instrumentation, lyrics, album cover design, playing live in stadiums, and much more. Perhaps it would be stretching it to say that music today wouldn't be what it is without The Beatles, but they provided the springboard for what followed and opened up new horizons for fellow artists. Okay, so their early releases likes of She Loves You may sound a bit simplistic now, but you have place what they did in the context of the period - 1963 ( and indeed 1970 when they split) were very different times from 2019. I rest my case m'lud. ps I do agree with you regards Paul Weller Agreed. I would also add that they had a global impact on the music and fashion industry opening the doors for other artists to follow. This has been said many times by other artists and fashion designers that the Beatles mad being British cool.
One more point |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Midlands Eagle 13 Nov 19 1.17pm | |
---|---|
My son was in the same class as Mat Osman's brother (Richard Osman of Pointless fame) at Warden Park School in Cuckfield he said adding a Willo like irrelevancy to the proceedings
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Midlands Eagle 13 Nov 19 1.19pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by punksnotdead
Overrated Liam Gallagher , Paul Weller, The Beatles I admire your subtle sense of humour
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
PalazioVecchio south pole 13 Nov 19 1.24pm | |
---|---|
agreed. also overrated : Oasis
Tom Waits
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Superfly The sun always shines in Catford 13 Nov 19 1.51pm | |
---|---|
Underrated : Cardiacs The epitome of a marmite band. Adored by their fanbase and despised by everyone else (including all of the music press) I've had one album since it's release in 1987 but recently bought the rest of their stuff. I now struggle to listen to anything else. Here's a taster For anyone looking to make a purchase, ignore the silly prices being asked on Amazon and go for the below fan run website. A portion of the proceeds go to (frontman/creative genius) Tim Smiths healthcare. He tragically has been hospitalised for over a decade any will almost certainly not write or perform again.
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Painter Croydon 13 Nov 19 2.07pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by topcat
It's hard to be objective as all the bands I don't like I also think are overrated and there are whole genres of music I don't get but others think are fantastic. Overrated I didn’t realise Fatboy Slim had ever been rated.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Invalid user 2019 13 Nov 19 2.13pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
overated: cold play ed sheeron and the jam underated: Lee Hazelwood OMD the beat OMD have still got it! I saw them live last year
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Invalid user 2019 13 Nov 19 2.15pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
My son was in the same class as Mat Osman's brother (Richard Osman of Pointless fame) at Warden Park School in Cuckfield he said adding a Willo like irrelevancy to the proceedings Uh oh, could this too turn into a Willo thread? Edited by dollardays (13 Nov 2019 2.16pm)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.