Did you not see Aston Villa away the season before last??

But actually what your saying is the opposite of proof, it's a biased theory based on a few games + happenings in which no one really knows what went on that you have equated to being conclsuive evidence that he's not good enough. Personally I'd rather take his entire career into consideration but what do I know. If he wants out of course there is no point keeping him but I'd love to see the new gaffer come in and convince him to hold out for another year, at least let us see what he's really capable of if there is any possibility of it happening.

We're the Arthur over ere!

Sure I read somewhere that his stats in the prem games he did play were absolutely terrible. Worse than any other keeper in the prem.

Was I imagining it or does anyone else remember and is there a link?

When you're thinking about which goalie?

"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Don't know about that but his saves per game and goals conceded per game were both worse than Hennessey's. Didn't really see that much of him but from what I did see he cost at least one goal and nearly a couple more with his quick distribution which was just too quick for our players. Also, the two close-range headers against Liverpool showed a lack of confidence in coming for crosses. Free him.

I was thinking about Hennessey. However, I haven't seen anything of Mandanda to think he is a viable alternative either. He seems to be a homesick, sick-note to me.

The only point that I was trying to make was that shot-stopping is only a part of being a goalkeeper; so mistakes leading directly to goals is only part of the problem.