A nationality is a concept subject to legal definitions and change.

Genes are a physical reality.

If you are genetically European your location is hardly relevant. Rudyard Kipling was born in India and spent a good deal of his youth there and loved the country....no one mistook Kipling for being Indian, least of all himself.

As for the immigrant question, don't get lost in the argument. My point answered the claim that America was always a land of immigrants....which is a leftist meme that deliberately tries to give the impression that America was open.

It wasn't....America's constitution specifically stated only Europeans may come.

I answered the point because it's deliberate disinformation and hence irritating.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2020 2.21am)

European Christians also built the infrastructure, the cities and towns, agriculture, judiciary, the political and social systems and everything that modern America is based on. Ironically much of which has now been subverted and is being used against them.

Americans use to get sold the concept of nationality quite strongly.

Nationality is used as a tool for unity but the wider you make the genetic base the harder it is to pull the woold over people's eyes.

It's like the term British, now it's used by anyone here, whose allegiances are elsewhere because their genetics and family come from there. This isn't true for everyone but it is for a high percent.

It's Kipling in reverse.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2020 9.54am)

Yes.

You would have to read back to see my point.

Was your point that the democrats view that America is a land of immigrants is not true?

So if you agree with this "If you are going to use the genetics argument surely the only true "Americans" are the indigenous peoples the Native Americans, so everyone else is an immigrant" which you did above, surely all immigration from all counties should considered normal.