You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!
November 24 2024 3.30am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!

Previous Topic | Next Topic


Page 25 of 43 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

  

MikeCrete Flag Crete 22 Jul 20 9.16am Send a Private Message to MikeCrete Add MikeCrete as a friend

We have let Camarasa go without giving him a chance, we never really gave Sorloth a proper run at being number 9, we never play Meyer in the middle, AWB only got into the team because there was literally no one else, even though Wilf said he was his most difficult opponent. Lokilo left without getting a chance etc etc.
We need to have a different approach available rather than just the same old team, tactics, lack of subs every game. The opposition knows exactly how we will play, even teams on a poor run of form & a losing streak know we won't be going at them from the start. It is the most boring football I have seen in over 50 years at Selhurst. Enough of it, please go Roy, because next season will be ugly for all concerned as it stands.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Jul 20 9.18am Send a Private Message to Rudi Hedman Add Rudi Hedman as a friend

Good posts being made.

 


COYP

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
EddieMac Flag 22 Jul 20 9.20am Send a Private Message to EddieMac Add EddieMac as a friend

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

All very fair points well made. The issue I believe is Roy has taken this group of players as far as he can. We are not going to change the entire team over night so the core of the team is going to remain pretty much unchanged with a few new faces thrown in. He only has a one year contract anyway so what is the real point of him staying. I think a new manager with fresh ideas might just scrape us through the coming season, alas I fear Roy will not.

The choices are limited however, we may well be damned if we do change, damned if we don't. Parish needs to realise what a crucial point in our recent history this is and convince his spendthrift co-conspirators that they need to speculate to accumulate.

But do you not think that mot of our players have taken their careers as far as they can go and if all we are going to do is sign the bare minimum again then it is better to stick with Roy for another year ? Without backing I just can’t see any manager getting a tune from that squad and If we are going to buy the bare minimum then best to stick with Roy. This transfer window is critical for our club, but at least we have started off on the right track signing Ferguson. I have no hopes of next season being pretty but I can live with that if it ends up better in the long run. It is down to Parish and co now how we proceed.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jul 20 9.35am Send a Private Message to southnorwoodhill Add southnorwoodhill as a friend

Originally posted by EddieMac

But do you not think that mot of our players have taken their careers as far as they can go and if all we are going to do is sign the bare minimum again then it is better to stick with Roy for another year ? Without backing I just can’t see any manager getting a tune from that squad and If we are going to buy the bare minimum then best to stick with Roy. This transfer window is critical for our club, but at least we have started off on the right track signing Ferguson. I have no hopes of next season being pretty but I can live with that if it ends up better in the long run. It is down to Parish and co now how we proceed.

Food for thought:
[Link]
We even had Adebayor on the books. 15th, 42 points

And:
[Link]
No Zaha - 11th 45 points

Edited by southnorwoodhill (22 Jul 2020 10.03am)

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 22 Jul 20 10.22am Send a Private Message to Gary St.Andrews Add Gary St.Andrews as a friend

The season is nearly over thank god and we have not adapted to post lockdown very well. With that in mind along with the never ending injuries to all the defensive positions again, aren’t we being a bit harsh on Roy here?

My feeling is he has pulled off a miracle in keeping us in the Premiership on a budget of 8 million over 3 years. There are a lot of teams in the Championship and Division 1 that have spent more than that and have crashed and burnt.

Cut him some slack and look towards the 20/21 season...

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Jul 20 10.23am Send a Private Message to NEILLO Add NEILLO as a friend

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

No you couldn’t.

Or are you another ex palace trainee lurking on this website, denied a career in professional football by a career ending knee injury?

By the way Sorloth has netted 29 times, a record for the club by a foreign player. Could you do that?

Edited by Maine Eagle (22 Jul 2020 12.17am)

Clubs don't always get it right when releasing players.

As someone pointed out, De Bruyne and Salah were let go by Chelsea.

Hindsight's a wonderful thing, but if you had seen Sorloth play, in the flesh, as I did you would not have foreseen him being successful at Championship level let alone the Premier League.

By the way, I was talking about Hodgson ( and Ray Lew ) with a couple of ex Fulham players last weekend. They thought training was dull, repetitive and not particularly enjoyable. They also recognised the benefits of what it helped them to achieve in matches. Both appreciated Roy's man management and Ray's support.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Jul 20 10.24am Send a Private Message to EverybodyDannsNow Add EverybodyDannsNow as a friend

Originally posted by EddieMac

Believe me I find the football at the moment absolutely awful to watch and just as boring as you do and like everyone else on here I am angry most Saturday afternoons and I ask myself why do I put myself through this and I don’t always defend Roy as sometimes he boils my blood.

But.. as I said yesterday when I calm down after a game I look at the squad and say to myself what other players can he play? We have played a lot of the season with long term injuries to Benteke, Schlupp, Townsend, Sakho, Kelly, and then we have other players have missed a lot of games. Tomkins has also missed a lot of games.

We have 1 right back who has been a great servant to the club but is now out of his depth and should only be a squad player.

1 out and out striker who coupled with injuries and god knows what else can’t even kick a ball let alone score.

Our lack of left sided players cripples us in a lot of games with McCarthur at times covering that role. These just are some of the issues, then we have an ageing squad and we must have the slowest combines squad in the history of football which is a massive reason why we play as we do. When you have Dann, Sakho and Ward, in your defence it would be criminal to leave them exposed. All of this then we have a lot of players who are just not good enough anymore. None of this is Roy’s fault. He has tried to get a right back since AWB left but the club failed, he has tried to get a striker but the club let him down. The club won’t spend the money for reasons unknown to us fans and this is where we are.

The team basically picks itself every week and then when you look at the bench what are the options? Meyer or Riedewald. Riedewald is a centre back or defensive midfielder so why people scream for him to change a game I’ll never know. In my opinion from what Iv seen his best position is on the bench. Then we have Meyer who may just be at the wrong club but he hasn’t done anything to warrant a starting place he has had a lot of time to impress in training at least. ( I think there is more than meets the eye on the Meyer situation). We have the young players who again are not good enough because if they were they would play. People accuse Roy of only picking favourites but there is no way in hell that he would not play someone if they were better than someone else. From what I seen of our young lads they will have careers in league 1 or 2.

Yes, our football is awful. Yes it is boring, but Roy doesn’t tell the players to not score to not hit a pass to a team mate to not take a decent corner. We play most games with 3 out and out attacking players, It is not as if we play 5-4-1 just hoofing long balls up to a big man, Roy has is flaws but our players have more flaws and the lack of signings is criminal.

A good post and lots of valid points - as I’ve said a few times, I don’t think recognising the lack of investment absolves Roy of all blame, but I do absolutely agree that it’s the main contributing factor to our poor performances.

However, as has been alluded to, we have put together better seasons with worst squads than this. Our goal scoring return is one of the worst ever in the Prem, and there’s no way I can accept this is one of the worst teams to ever turn out in the league. So we’ve underperformed, in my opinion.

The other point is in a team who struggle to create chances due to a relative lack of quality, set pieces are a huge opportunity, and we’ve never been worst at them - there is no clear routine or plan to our set pieces.. Dann scored 2 in 14/15, 5 in 15/16 and 3 in 16/17... he has 1 in the last 3 seasons. Admittedly he plays less games these days, but he was a constant threat under managers who utilised set pieces properly. Roy doesn’t bother.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 22 Jul 20 10.24am Send a Private Message to HesHereHesThere Add HesHereHesThere as a friend

What really jars me is that after the amount of time we’ve been in the PL and the amount of money that we’ve had the squad is piss poor and the style of football makes my teeth itch. It’s not where any of us would expect us to be after so long in the PL but this dogs breakfast sits firmly in Parish’s lap. I not saying I could do any better running a football club cos I wouldn’t want to in the first place but he just can’t do it. Hat off to him for trying but he needs to get out now and handover to someone who knows what they’re doing. He’ll have his legacy the CPFC academy and he helped save the club but he’s obviously been the issue for previous managers hence the management Merry go round. His silence speak volumes at the moment as any minor success and he pipes in the papers but in all honesty he should sell up...

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Jul 20 10.27am Send a Private Message to NEILLO Add NEILLO as a friend

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Good posts being made.

Yes I agree.

Also good to see that gradually people are realising that this is not all of Roy Hodgson's fault....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
jeeagles Flag 22 Jul 20 10.27am

Originally posted by EddieMac
But do you not think that mot of our players have taken their careers as far as they can go and if all we are going to do is sign the bare minimum again then it is better to stick with Roy for another year ? Without backing I just can’t see any manager getting a tune from that squad and If we are going to buy the bare minimum then best to stick with Roy. This transfer window is critical for our club, but at least we have started off on the right track signing Ferguson. I have no hopes of next season being pretty but I can live with that if it ends up better in the long run. It is down to Parish and co now how we proceed.

I think a lot of our players are playing within them selves whilst many other haven't been given a chance - but that debate is going round in circles.

I have a feeling that the club knew Roy's very pragmatic system would keep us up as should be expected base on our players and wage bill. They new that there was no real chance he would push us any further based on his incredibly risk adverse approach, so have refused to back him, instead, focusing on correcting the finances after BFS spent a fortune. Hoping that the investment under BFS would tie us over for the short term.

Now we are getting to the point where we haven't spent lots and many of the contracts are expiring. I hope there is now money in the bank to back a new manager (hopefully Dyche) for a long term project, rather than spending money on an outgoing manager.

Next season would be a great opportunity for a new manager to decide what players he wants to keep, clear out the dead wood, and sign who they want.

Looking at the league, there's not much to choose from in terms of the managers of the bottom 10 sides, but there must be a manager out their who's more progressive than Hodgson.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Quote this post in a reply
PatrickA Flag London 22 Jul 20 10.38am Send a Private Message to PatrickA Add PatrickA as a friend

And with equal validity some people are beginning to understandl that part of the problem is Hodgson’s fault.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 22 Jul 20 10.43am Send a Private Message to Gary St.Andrews Add Gary St.Andrews as a friend

Ok let’s look at it another way , take Liverpool’s back 4 out along with Salah and Mane, throw in a couple of injures in key positions and I think you will find they will below us.

What I am saying is we are doing what we can with what we have got. Any team that has only spent 8 million quid over 3 seasons in the Premiership is going to find it tricky to compete.

Norwich didn’t spend and they fell through the trapped door, Watford will go the same way too!

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply

  

Page 25 of 43 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!