Jordan Rhodes (suggestion)

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jordan Rhodes (suggestion)

Page 25 of 29 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

Plane Bromley 07 Aug 14 10.51am
Quote geoff at 07 Aug 2014 10.43am When a player is on a contract that contract determines his terms and conditions of employment, including salary. When it comes to a player sale the only influence a contract will have is the asking price. Someone with 3 years left on a contract will normally command a bigger fee than someone of similar ability with 6 months left on their contract. If and when they join a new club, after negotiations, they sign a new contract with their new employer with new terms and conditions, including new salary. Simples! For everyone except Syd!!! One thing that's bothered me with Syd's scenario, who dishes out these contracts? Does a player get one given to him by the FA at 18 years of age and he has to keep it 'til he retires, which nobody would be able to predict?
Alert a moderator to this post

Plane

Bromley 07 Aug 14 10.51am

Quote geoff at 07 Aug 2014 10.43am

When a player is on a contract that contract determines his terms and conditions of employment, including salary. When it comes to a player sale the only influence a contract will have is the asking price. Someone with 3 years left on a contract will normally command a bigger fee than someone of similar ability with 6 months left on their contract.
If and when they join a new club, after negotiations, they sign a new contract with their new employer with new terms and conditions, including new salary. Simples!

For everyone except Syd!!!

One thing that's bothered me with Syd's scenario, who dishes out these contracts? Does a player get one given to him by the FA at 18 years of age and he has to keep it 'til he retires, which nobody would be able to predict?

Alert a moderator to this post

highbury eagle Islington 07 Aug 14 11.44am
We digress. Presume no word on Rhodes? Life is the same as it always will be, Easy as picking foxes from a tree. M Bolan
Alert a moderator to this post

highbury eagle

Islington 07 Aug 14 11.44am

Send a Private Message to highbury eagle

We digress.
Presume no word on Rhodes?

Life is the same as it always will be,
Easy as picking foxes from a tree.
M Bolan

Alert a moderator to this post

diao84 07 Aug 14 1.46pm
This thread is funny A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player.
Alert a moderator to this post

diao84

07 Aug 14 1.46pm

This thread is funny

A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player.

Alert a moderator to this post

Moose In the sewer pipe... 07 Aug 14 2.49pm
I'm sure syd will be back momentarily to clarify his position. Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.
Alert a moderator to this post

Moose

In the sewer pipe... 07 Aug 14 2.49pm

I'm sure syd will be back momentarily to clarify his position.

Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

Alert a moderator to this post

black eagle. south croydon. 07 Aug 14 2.55pm
Quote highbury eagle at 07 Aug 2014 11.44am We digress. Pre. no word on Rhodes? Yss his staying at Blackburn having just signed a bumper new deal
Alert a moderator to this post

black eagle.

south croydon. 07 Aug 14 2.55pm

Quote highbury eagle at 07 Aug 2014 11.44am

We digress.
Pre. no word on Rhodes?

Yss his staying at Blackburn having just signed a bumper new deal

Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 07 Aug 14 5.05pm
Quote Moose at 07 Aug 2014 2.49pm I'm sure syd will be back momentarily to clarify his position. Or muddy the waters more.
Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko

Deurne Holland 07 Aug 14 5.05pm

Quote Moose at 07 Aug 2014 2.49pm

I'm sure syd will be back momentarily to clarify his position.

Or muddy the waters more.

Alert a moderator to this post

est1905 07 Aug 14 5.46pm
Quote Sg Bilko at 06 Aug 2014 8.00pm Quote est1905 at 06 Aug 2014 5.50pm Quote Sg Bilko at 06 Aug 2014 12.50pm Quote Plane at 06 Aug 2014 12.21pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 06 Aug 2014 11.30am Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Aug 2014 11.11am Quote DannyDyer at 06 Aug 2014 11.08am Sorry but you are really so wrong I can't believe you actually watch/listen/read about transfer news?!? You really have no idea what you're talking about, but I'm not going to get into an argument. I've explained as articulately as I can how it works. Let's leave it at that. Up to readers if they think you're a more credible source of information. Re: Shaw, when a club wants to buy a player they talk to him first (just like any job interview). If, in that conversation, the player makes it clear that when contract time comes around he'll be wanting a rise to 90K a week then the prospective new employer may well say "no thanks". Edited by sydtheeagle (06 Aug 2014 11.15am) He is right and you are so far off the mark it is laughable , I suggest as you do on various other threads , back you points up with a credible link ? Old contracts are not transferred for one , and clubs don't speak to the players first like a job interview as that is classed as tapping the player up ( although yes I'm fully aware it goes on) Is the correct answer. As pointed out by Dave which Syd decided to ignore. Syd, perhaps you should stick to rugby, you really haven't much idea about football Contracts in European football are between a specific club and a player, and are non-transferable. Plus no club is allowed to approach a player under contract to another club, without first asking the club he is contracted to, to do so comes under the heading "Illegal Approach", clubs normally just don't do that the penalty's are to high, agents are usually the ones who turn the heads of players. Edited by Sg Bilko (06 Aug 2014 12.52pm) That goes on all the time. It might be an 'illegal approach' but its very difficult to prove if neither club nor player admit to it. Do you honestly believe Real Madrid had absolutely no contact with Ronaldo or his representatives BEFORE the agreed a fee with Man United? Really? Very naïve if so. Naïve definitely not, do you know how it works in football because I do, and it's not like in the legal system where you are innocent until proven guilty, in football it's the other way round if an FA brings a charge against you, it's up to you to prove your not guilty, and that's hard when those on the other side of the table are not listening, that's why very few walk out of an FA hearing without some sort of penalty. [Link] And yes clubs do get punished for an Illegal Approach, both Liverpool, and Everton, plus Celtic, and Arsenal also Chelsea have been found guilty, both Dwight York and Ashley Cole were found guilty of the same offence. Oh and by the way yes I do think Real Madrid did everything by the book in the Ronaldo and Bale transfers, if there was any wrong doing it was by the agents, not the clubs, if you think the FA and the FL don't keep a close eye on clubs and players, then your the naïve one, because they do, you would be surprised what they find out or know, everything and I mean everything is tightly controlled. Hmm, Whatever then. I guessed you were the type to admit they might be wrong now and again instead of stubbornly clinging to a point of view that has flaws. You say if there was any wrong doing in Ronaldo's move it was agents. Well call me a cynic but I don't really believe a transfer of that magnitude would happen unless the buying club were using every trick in the book (legal or not) to make it happen. You clearly do know quite a bit about what you are talking about. You are just very very far from the only person that's all. And many don't see things quite as black and white as you do.
Alert a moderator to this post

est1905

07 Aug 14 5.46pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 06 Aug 2014 8.00pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Aug 2014 5.50pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 06 Aug 2014 12.50pm

Quote Plane at 06 Aug 2014 12.21pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 06 Aug 2014 11.30am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Aug 2014 11.11am

Quote DannyDyer at 06 Aug 2014 11.08am

Sorry but you are really so wrong I can't believe you actually watch/listen/read about transfer news?!?

You really have no idea what you're talking about, but I'm not going to get into an argument. I've explained as articulately as I can how it works. Let's leave it at that. Up to readers if they think you're a more credible source of information.

Re: Shaw, when a club wants to buy a player they talk to him first (just like any job interview). If, in that conversation, the player makes it clear that when contract time comes around he'll be wanting a rise to 90K a week then the prospective new employer may well say "no thanks".

Edited by sydtheeagle (06 Aug 2014 11.15am)

He is right and you are so far off the mark it is laughable , I suggest as you do on various other threads , back you points up with a credible link ? Old contracts are not transferred for one , and clubs don't speak to the players first like a job interview as that is classed as tapping the player up ( although yes I'm fully aware it goes on)

Is the correct answer. As pointed out by Dave which Syd decided to ignore.

Syd, perhaps you should stick to rugby, you really haven't much idea about football

Contracts in European football are between a specific club and a player, and are non-transferable.

Plus no club is allowed to approach a player under contract to another club, without first asking the club he is contracted to, to do so comes under the heading "Illegal Approach", clubs normally just don't do that the penalty's are to high, agents are usually the ones who turn the heads of players.

Edited by Sg Bilko (06 Aug 2014 12.52pm)

That goes on all the time. It might be an 'illegal approach' but its very difficult to prove if neither club nor player admit to it. Do you honestly believe Real Madrid had absolutely no contact with Ronaldo or his representatives BEFORE the agreed a fee with Man United? Really? Very naïve if so.

Naïve definitely not, do you know how it works in football because I do, and it's not like in the legal system where you are innocent until proven guilty, in football it's the other way round if an FA brings a charge against you, it's up to you to prove your not guilty, and that's hard when those on the other side of the table are not listening, that's why very few walk out of an FA hearing without some sort of penalty. [Link]

And yes clubs do get punished for an Illegal Approach, both Liverpool, and Everton, plus Celtic, and Arsenal also Chelsea have been found guilty, both Dwight York and Ashley Cole were found guilty of the same offence.

Oh and by the way yes I do think Real Madrid did everything by the book in the Ronaldo and Bale transfers, if there was any wrong doing it was by the agents, not the clubs, if you think the FA and the FL don't keep a close eye on clubs and players, then your the naïve one, because they do, you would be surprised what they find out or know, everything and I mean everything is tightly controlled.

Hmm, Whatever then. I guessed you were the type to admit they might be wrong now and again instead of stubbornly clinging to a point of view that has flaws.
You say if there was any wrong doing in Ronaldo's move it was agents. Well call me a cynic but I don't really believe a transfer of that magnitude would happen unless the buying club were using every trick in the book (legal or not) to make it happen.
You clearly do know quite a bit about what you are talking about. You are just very very far from the only person that's all. And many don't see things quite as black and white as you do.

Alert a moderator to this post

highbury eagle Islington 07 Aug 14 10.17pm
Quote black eagle. at 07 Aug 2014 2.55pm Quote highbury eagle at 07 Aug 2014 11.44am We digress. Presume. no word on Rhodes? Yss his staying at Blackburn having just signed a bumper new deal Perhaps we could buy out his contract? Edited by highbury eagle (07 Aug 2014 10.18pm) Life is the same as it always will be, Easy as picking foxes from a tree. M Bolan
Alert a moderator to this post

highbury eagle

Islington 07 Aug 14 10.17pm

Quote black eagle. at 07 Aug 2014 2.55pm

Quote highbury eagle at 07 Aug 2014 11.44am

We digress.
Presume. no word on Rhodes?

Yss his staying at Blackburn having just signed a bumper new deal

Perhaps we could buy out his contract?

Edited by highbury eagle (07 Aug 2014 10.18pm)

Life is the same as it always will be,
Easy as picking foxes from a tree.
M Bolan

Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 08 Aug 14 8.00am
Quote est1905 at 07 Aug 2014 5.46pm Hmm, Whatever then. I guessed you were the type to admit they might be wrong now and again instead of stubbornly clinging to a point of view that has flaws. You say if there was any wrong doing in Ronaldo's move it was agents. Well call me a cynic but I don't really believe a transfer of that magnitude would happen unless the buying club were using every trick in the book (legal or not) to make it happen. You clearly do know quite a bit about what you are talking about. You are just very very far from the only person that's all. And many don't see things quite as black and white as you do. Oh come on please, at the time it was the biggest and most expensive transfer anywhere, and don't you think any wrong doing by either club would shown up, plus Man U were reluctant to let their star player go, so if there was any wrong doing by Real, United would for sure have lodged a complaint, they didn't Ronaldo wanted to go, he said it was the move he always dreamt of. There was no skullduggery, a legitimate offer was made to Man U for the player, the offer of £80m was accepted.
Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko

Deurne Holland 08 Aug 14 8.00am

Quote est1905 at 07 Aug 2014 5.46pm

Hmm, Whatever then. I guessed you were the type to admit they might be wrong now and again instead of stubbornly clinging to a point of view that has flaws.
You say if there was any wrong doing in Ronaldo's move it was agents. Well call me a cynic but I don't really believe a transfer of that magnitude would happen unless the buying club were using every trick in the book (legal or not) to make it happen.
You clearly do know quite a bit about what you are talking about. You are just very very far from the only person that's all. And many don't see things quite as black and white as you do.

Oh come on please, at the time it was the biggest and most expensive transfer anywhere, and don't you think any wrong doing by either club would shown up, plus Man U were reluctant to let their star player go, so if there was any wrong doing by Real, United would for sure have lodged a complaint, they didn't Ronaldo wanted to go, he said it was the move he always dreamt of.

There was no skullduggery, a legitimate offer was made to Man U for the player, the offer of £80m was accepted.

Alert a moderator to this post

braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 08 Aug 14 10.46am
Quote diao84 at 07 Aug 2014 1.46pm This thread is funny A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player. Actually I disagree with you. What you are doing is buying out a contract. And a lot of the time the fee is dependant on how long is left on the current contract. If this wasn't the case why does a player move for free when his contract expires. ‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
Alert a moderator to this post

braunstoneagle

the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 08 Aug 14 10.46am

Send a Private Message to braunstoneagle

Quote diao84 at 07 Aug 2014 1.46pm

This thread is funny

A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player.

Actually I disagree with you.

What you are doing is buying out a contract.

And a lot of the time the fee is dependant on how long is left on the current contract.

If this wasn't the case why does a player move for free when his contract expires.

‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway

Alert a moderator to this post

bexleydave Barnehurst 08 Aug 14 11.15am
Quote braunstoneagle at 08 Aug 2014 10.46am Quote diao84 at 07 Aug 2014 1.46pm This thread is funny A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player. Actually I disagree with you. What you are doing is buying out a contract. And a lot of the time the fee is dependant on how long is left on the current contract. If this wasn't the case why does a player move for free when his contract expires. Absolutely, which is what the majority are saying; (in general) the longer left on a contract, the more that player will cost. There is a minority (of one) who think that the opposite is the case, for reasons that remain unfathomable. Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)
Alert a moderator to this post

bexleydave

Barnehurst 08 Aug 14 11.15am

Quote braunstoneagle at 08 Aug 2014 10.46am

Quote diao84 at 07 Aug 2014 1.46pm

This thread is funny

A club does not buy a contract, they buy a player.

Actually I disagree with you.

What you are doing is buying out a contract.

And a lot of the time the fee is dependant on how long is left on the current contract.

If this wasn't the case why does a player move for free when his contract expires.

Absolutely, which is what the majority are saying; (in general) the longer left on a contract, the more that player will cost. There is a minority (of one) who think that the opposite is the case, for reasons that remain unfathomable.

Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Alert a moderator to this post

regal_eagle somewhere 08 Aug 14 1.04pm
I'm waiting for the clamber to sign him after he scores a brace or hat-trick against Cardiff tonight only for QPR to gazump at the last minute.
Alert a moderator to this post

regal_eagle

somewhere 08 Aug 14 1.04pm

I'm waiting for the clamber to sign him after he scores a brace or hat-trick against Cardiff tonight only for QPR to gazump at the last minute.

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 25 of 29 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Jordan Rhodes (suggestion)

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors