Paddy McNair (suggestion)

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Paddy McNair (suggestion)

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

mattteo 04 Jun 18 9.57am
You're taking the wrong thing out of my comment. It doesn;t matter if Sir Alex was asked to step down because of that (maybe it's just an impression I have, not about his last season as champion, but about everything in his last years at United, which made fans wishing for more offensive football and not playing Wes Brown or O'shea there instead of Rafael for example. It was an ongoing discussion back then). The point was that the players are not good on 3 or more positions. Let's not derail the thread talking about Ferguson. Yes, as coldsoneagle pointed out, there are some players like Milner or Azpilicueta who play very well wherever you put them, but these are rarities. They are very strong and very fast and would be good anywhere in defense or in defensive midfield. Disagree about Moses or Dier or Daley Blind though.
Alert a moderator to this post

mattteo

04 Jun 18 9.57am

You're taking the wrong thing out of my comment. It doesn;t matter if Sir Alex was asked to step down because of that (maybe it's just an impression I have, not about his last season as champion, but about everything in his last years at United, which made fans wishing for more offensive football and not playing Wes Brown or O'shea there instead of Rafael for example. It was an ongoing discussion back then).

The point was that the players are not good on 3 or more positions. Let's not derail the thread talking about Ferguson.

Yes, as coldsoneagle pointed out, there are some players like Milner or Azpilicueta who play very well wherever you put them, but these are rarities.
They are very strong and very fast and would be good anywhere in defense or in defensive midfield. Disagree about Moses or Dier or Daley Blind though.

Alert a moderator to this post

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jun 18 10.07am
Originally posted by mattteo You're taking the wrong thing out of my comment. It doesn;t matter if Sir Alex was asked to step down because of that (maybe it's just an impression I have, not about his last season as champion, but about everything in his last years at United, which made fans wishing for more offensive football and not playing Wes Brown or O'shea there instead of Rafael for example. It was an ongoing discussion back then). The point was that the players are not good on 3 or more positions. Let's not derail the thread talking about Ferguson. Yes, as coldsoneagle pointed out, there are some players like Milner or Azpilicueta who play very well wherever you put them, but these are rarities. They are very strong and very fast and would be good anywhere in defense or in defensive midfield. Disagree about Moses or Dier or Daley Blind though. I can understand your desire to deflect attention away from what was a categoric statement which you now state is an "Impression". But you have made your view patently clear about players who perform in a variety of positions and of course opinions are open to scrutiny. Depends on the player of course and versatility is often portrayed as a positive rather than a negative in respect of certain individuals. Edited by Willo (04 Jun 2018 10.09am)
Alert a moderator to this post

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jun 18 10.07am

Originally posted by mattteo

The point was that the players are not good on 3 or more positions. Let's not derail the thread talking about Ferguson.

I can understand your desire to deflect attention away from what was a categoric statement which you now state is an "Impression".

But you have made your view patently clear about players who perform in a variety of positions and of course opinions are open to scrutiny.
Depends on the player of course and versatility is often portrayed as a positive rather than a negative in respect of certain individuals.

Edited by Willo (04 Jun 2018 10.09am)

Alert a moderator to this post

mattteo 04 Jun 18 10.42am
[Link] Read the last sentence. It's just the way I remember it, having lived through those times
Alert a moderator to this post

mattteo

04 Jun 18 10.42am

[Link]

Read the last sentence. It's just the way I remember it, having lived through those times

Alert a moderator to this post

dp Tunbridge Wells 04 Jun 18 11.54am
Ok mattteo, I can understand why you want to move on from that comment. It seems like Brighton are stepping up the hunt for him anyway. Edited by dp (04 Jun 2018 12.20pm)
Alert a moderator to this post

Tunbridge Wells 04 Jun 18 11.54am

Ok mattteo, I can understand why you want to move on from that comment.

It seems like Brighton are stepping up the hunt for him anyway.

Edited by dp (04 Jun 2018 12.20pm)

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Paddy McNair (suggestion)

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors