Jonny Evans (suggestion)

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jonny Evans (suggestion)

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jul 15 6.25pm
Johnny Evans as well as playing at centre-half has played at right-back. He is very good at coming out of defence with the ball, is a good user of the ball and has pace.
Alert a moderator to this post

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jul 15 6.25pm

Johnny Evans as well as playing at centre-half has played at right-back. He is very good at coming out of defence with the ball, is a good user of the ball and has pace.

Alert a moderator to this post

GlaziertoEagle Coventry 23 Jul 15 7.06pm
Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap! They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem. Woeful. Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE. What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s* but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s* but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat. You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club. I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans. Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm) He's s* because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s* for us and still s* , so if we sell bolasie , he Must be s* to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann. I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point. As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'.
Alert a moderator to this post

GlaziertoEagle

Coventry 23 Jul 15 7.06pm

Send a Private Message to GlaziertoEagle

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm

Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm

I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap!

They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem.

Woeful.

Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE.

What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s*** but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s*** but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat.

You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club.

I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans.

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm)

He's s*** because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s*** for us and still s*** , so if we sell bolasie , he
Must be s*** to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann.

I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point.

As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'.

Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7 Croydon 23 Jul 15 7.43pm
Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap! They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem. Woeful. Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE. What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s* but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s* but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat. You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club. I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans. Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm) He's s* because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s* for us and still s* , so if we sell bolasie , he Must be s* to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann. I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point. As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'. Doubt it, at 2:05 Carrick said "he's s***" so I;d suggest he is implying that his career will go in the same way as theirs currently is Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 7.46pm) 26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7

Croydon 23 Jul 15 7.43pm

Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm

Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm

I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap!

They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem.

Woeful.

Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE.

You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club.

I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans.

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm)

I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point.

Doubt it, at 2:05 Carrick said "he's s***" so I;d suggest he is implying that his career will go in the same way as theirs currently is

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 7.46pm)

26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Alert a moderator to this post

comeonyoueagles20 caterham 23 Jul 15 7.44pm
Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap! They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem. Woeful. Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE. What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s* but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s* but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat. You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club. I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans. Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm) He's s* because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s* for us and still s* , so if we sell bolasie , he Must be s* to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann. I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point. As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'. Having re read the post , I think you may be right , my bad haha , for me Evans is an improvement on the other two , and at 27 has his best years ahead of him, he would be a good option of we are unable to get Williams which seems unlikely.
Alert a moderator to this post

comeonyoueagles20

caterham 23 Jul 15 7.44pm

Send a Private Message to comeonyoueagles20

Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm

Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm

I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap!

They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem.

Woeful.

Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE.

You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club.

I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans.

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm)

I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point.

Having re read the post , I think you may be right , my bad haha , for me Evans is an improvement on the other two , and at 27 has his best years ahead of him, he would be a good option of we are unable to get Williams which seems unlikely.

Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7 Croydon 23 Jul 15 7.48pm
Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 7.44pm Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap! They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem. Woeful. Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE. What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s* but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s* but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat. You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club. I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans. Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm) He's s* because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s* for us and still s* , so if we sell bolasie , he Must be s* to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann. I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point. As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'. Having re read the post , I think you may be right , my bad haha , for me Evans is an improvement on the other two , and at 27 has his best years ahead of him, he would be a good option of we are unable to get Williams which seems unlikely. But he also wrote this: "He's s***! Look at what happens when the United "ex" stars go to other clubs in the Prem! Sunderland defense - SHOCKING!" 26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7

Croydon 23 Jul 15 7.48pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 7.44pm

Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm

Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm

I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap!

They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem.

Woeful.

Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE.

You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club.

I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans.

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm)

I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point.

But he also wrote this:

"He's s***!

Look at what happens when the United "ex" stars go to other clubs in the Prem!

Sunderland defense - SHOCKING!"

26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Alert a moderator to this post

comeonyoueagles20 caterham 23 Jul 15 7.53pm
Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 7.48pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 7.44pm Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap! They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem. Woeful. Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE. What has that got to do with anything? When Will Buckley left Brighton he was s* but it doesn't mean Murray was. When Butterfield left us he was s* but Hill played in the PL. When Cleverley left he was pretty average but I'd take Pogba in a heartbeat. You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club. I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans. Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm) He's s* because brown and Oshea were , that's flawless logic , kebe was s* for us and still s* , so if we sell bolasie , he Must be s* to!! Oshea and Brown were decent for Sunderland when they initially left , agreed the last few years they have been poor , but one is 35 and the other one has suffered from injuries his whole career and is also in his thirties. Evans is a decent cb when fully fit , and would be an excellent partner for dann. I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point. As I read it, he isn't saying 'Evans is crap based on Brown and O'Shea being crap', rather 'Evans was good playing with Brown and O'Shea and this is even more impressive if you consider how badly those 2 have been since they moved to Sunderland'. Having re read the post , I think you may be right , my bad haha , for me Evans is an improvement on the other two , and at 27 has his best years ahead of him, he would be a good option of we are unable to get Williams which seems unlikely. But he also wrote this: "He's s***! Look at what happens when the United "ex" stars go to other clubs in the Prem! Sunderland defense - SHOCKING!" Aww I missed that , funny thing is , if you take away the freak result where they got beaten 8-0/8-1 I can't remember , sunderlands shocking defence conceded less goals than ours.
Alert a moderator to this post

comeonyoueagles20

caterham 23 Jul 15 7.53pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 7.48pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 7.44pm

Quote GlaziertoEagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.06pm

Quote comeonyoueagles20 at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ambrose7 at 23 Jul 2015 4.44pm

Quote Carrick at 23 Jul 2015 3.01pm

I really rate him along side the likes of Wes Brown and John O'Shea, who when they left ManU were crap!

They are the reasons Sunderland struggle every year in the prem.

Woeful.

Ok back up for us but id rather DD and Brede ahead of JE.

You can't base the ability of one player on that of another purely because they once played in roughly the same position at the same club.

I'd be astounded if you can find a single supporter of another club who would take either Brede Hangeland or Damien Delaney over Jonny Evans.

Edited by ambrose7 (23 Jul 2015 4.46pm)

I'm sure Carrick can comment for himself but I think these comments may be misunderstanding his point.

But he also wrote this:

"He's s***!

Look at what happens when the United "ex" stars go to other clubs in the Prem!

Sunderland defense - SHOCKING!"

Aww I missed that , funny thing is , if you take away the freak result where they got beaten 8-0/8-1 I can't remember , sunderlands shocking defence conceded less goals than ours.

Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85 Sydney 24 Jul 15 12.49am
Evans would be a class signing, anyone suggesting otherwise is wrong, pure and simply wrong. People say that Jose can pick a player, SAF could also pick a player. He has played in the Champions League against some of the best strikers in the world and learnt from players like Ferdinand (when good) Stam and Vidic, I would have him here in a heartbeat.
Alert a moderator to this post

seltz85

Sydney 24 Jul 15 12.49am

Evans would be a class signing, anyone suggesting otherwise is wrong, pure and simply wrong. People say that Jose can pick a player, SAF could also pick a player. He has played in the Champions League against some of the best strikers in the world and learnt from players like Ferdinand (when good) Stam and Vidic, I would have him here in a heartbeat.

Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 8.01am
For the avoidance of doubt I think he's s* And yes I think our existing targets: Williams, collocini, Chester are far superior than JE. And yes I am comparing to o's* and brown at Sunderland. What I am saying and interesting you compare to cleverly. These manU youngsters (the new breed) are distinctly average players who get found out when they leave and haven't got Rio, vidic etc saving their arse!!! Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.
Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick

In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 8.01am

For the avoidance of doubt
I think he's s***

And yes I think our existing targets:
Williams, collocini, Chester are far superior than JE.

And yes I am comparing to o's*** and brown at Sunderland.

What I am saying and interesting you compare to cleverly. These manU youngsters (the new breed) are distinctly average players who get found out when they leave and haven't got Rio, vidic etc saving their arse!!!

Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.

Alert a moderator to this post

The Dolphin 24 Jul 15 11.22am
I wouldn't want him at any price. A nasty bit of work as well as not very good - happier with Delaney than him.
Alert a moderator to this post

The Dolphin

24 Jul 15 11.22am

I wouldn't want him at any price.
A nasty bit of work as well as not very good - happier with Delaney than him.

Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 12.31pm
^^^ what he said Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.
Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick

In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 12.31pm

^^^ what he said

Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7 Croydon 24 Jul 15 12.34pm
Quote Carrick at 24 Jul 2015 8.01am For the avoidance of doubt I think he's s* And yes I think our existing targets: Williams, collocini, Chester are far superior than JE. And yes I am comparing to o's* and brown at Sunderland. What I am saying and interesting you compare to cleverly. These manU youngsters (the new breed) are distinctly average players who get found out when they leave and haven't got Rio, vidic etc saving their arse!!! On the point of Cleverley, it was widely known he was average but that is average by United's standard - Villa wanted him back and Everton were quick to snap him up. Are players that aren't standout performers at United not good enough for us? Who at United would be good enough for us then? Rooney, De Gea, Mata, anymore? We signed an Arsenal reserve player on loan last year but now a United player with 200 appearances, Champions League experience and in the prime of his career isn't good enough? This Cabaye signing has driven people's expectations mad And on your point of James Chester, he's 1 year younger. One got shipped out of United and one played for them 200 times. To say the one that got shipped is far superior is a little presumptious don't you think? Edited by ambrose7 (24 Jul 2015 12.40pm) 26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
Alert a moderator to this post

ambrose7

Croydon 24 Jul 15 12.34pm

Quote Carrick at 24 Jul 2015 8.01am

For the avoidance of doubt
I think he's s***

And yes I think our existing targets:
Williams, collocini, Chester are far superior than JE.

And yes I am comparing to o's*** and brown at Sunderland.

On the point of Cleverley, it was widely known he was average but that is average by United's standard - Villa wanted him back and Everton were quick to snap him up.

Are players that aren't standout performers at United not good enough for us? Who at United would be good enough for us then? Rooney, De Gea, Mata, anymore?

We signed an Arsenal reserve player on loan last year but now a United player with 200 appearances, Champions League experience and in the prime of his career isn't good enough? This Cabaye signing has driven people's expectations mad

And on your point of James Chester, he's 1 year younger. One got shipped out of United and one played for them 200 times. To say the one that got shipped is far superior is a little presumptious don't you think?

Edited by ambrose7 (24 Jul 2015 12.40pm)

26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 12.48pm
I think that this is my opinion which we are all entitled of. Therefore pleasestop trying to make me change my own opinion with pittiful facts. I have watched him and Chester play in the Prem, and believe Chester is a better option for us, and that i would rather our existing back up or partners for Dann to remain instead of getting JE. Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.
Alert a moderator to this post

Carrick

In the Premierleague 24 Jul 15 12.48pm

I think that this is my opinion which we are all entitled of.

Therefore pleasestop trying to make me change my own opinion with pittiful facts.

I have watched him and Chester play in the Prem, and believe Chester is a better option for us, and that i would rather our existing back up or partners for Dann to remain instead of getting JE.

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Jonny Evans (suggestion)

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors