Pulis makes official complaint about Howard Webb

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pulis makes official complaint about Howard Webb

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

adrian b Landrindod, Wales 14 Mar 14 2.06pm
Quote Plane at 14 Mar 2014 1.34pm Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision. Bit of a stupid argument isn't it? If we get marginal decisions that go for us then I would assume they're going against another team, it's up to them to complain? Yes, you're correct. Just looking for some balance here. When will it happen, do you think, that the authorities, on investigation of a complaint, turn over a decision?
Alert a moderator to this post

adrian b

Landrindod, Wales 14 Mar 14 2.06pm

Quote Plane at 14 Mar 2014 1.34pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm

I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision.

Bit of a stupid argument isn't it? If we get marginal decisions that go for us then I would assume they're going against another team, it's up to them to complain?

Yes, you're correct. Just looking for some balance here. When will it happen, do you think, that the authorities, on investigation of a complaint, turn over a decision?

Alert a moderator to this post

Plane Bromley 14 Mar 14 2.25pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 2.06pm Quote Plane at 14 Mar 2014 1.34pm Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision. Bit of a stupid argument isn't it? If we get marginal decisions that go for us then I would assume they're going against another team, it's up to them to complain? Yes, you're correct. Just looking for some balance here. When will it happen, do you think, that the authorities, on investigation of a complaint, turn over a decision? I realise you playing devils advocate but as I said earlier, if these things don't get challenged then where does it end. My feeling on the tackle on Bolasie was a yellow was the right thing but I'm not a ref. For us, never, for the big guns whenever they want/need it, just look at when Liverpool were let into Europe, forcing us out.
Alert a moderator to this post

Plane

Bromley 14 Mar 14 2.25pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 2.06pm

Quote Plane at 14 Mar 2014 1.34pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm

Bit of a stupid argument isn't it? If we get marginal decisions that go for us then I would assume they're going against another team, it's up to them to complain?

Yes, you're correct. Just looking for some balance here. When will it happen, do you think, that the authorities, on investigation of a complaint, turn over a decision?

I realise you playing devils advocate but as I said earlier, if these things don't get challenged then where does it end. My feeling on the tackle on Bolasie was a yellow was the right thing but I'm not a ref.

For us, never, for the big guns whenever they want/need it, just look at when Liverpool were let into Europe, forcing us out.

Alert a moderator to this post

croydon proud Any european country i fancy! 14 Mar 14 2.43pm
im all for it, wont hurt a ref to know when he comes to sp if he makes a bad call against us hes gona know about it in a few days, thats how sir alex got so many penalties at old traff!
Alert a moderator to this post

croydon proud

Any european country i fancy! 14 Mar 14 2.43pm

im all for it, wont hurt a ref to know when he comes to sp if he makes a bad call against us hes gona know about it in a few days, thats how sir alex got so many penalties at old traff!

Alert a moderator to this post

blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 14 Mar 14 2.58pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded. It about time somebody faced up to the deplorable standard of referees so far this season. Webb was fu**ing terrible.
Alert a moderator to this post

blind eagle

Covington.Tennessee 14 Mar 14 2.58pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am

Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded.

It about time somebody faced up to the deplorable standard of referees so far this season. Webb was fu**ing terrible.

Alert a moderator to this post

pyroart East Sussex, previously SE19 14 Mar 14 3.07pm
Quote blind eagle at 14 Mar 2014 2.58pm Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded. It about time somebody faced up to the deplorable standard of referees so far this season. Webb was fu**ing terrible. too true if you don't complain nothing will ever get done its a pity a few more don't lodge official complaints .
Alert a moderator to this post

pyroart

East Sussex, previously SE19 14 Mar 14 3.07pm

Quote blind eagle at 14 Mar 2014 2.58pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am

Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded.

It about time somebody faced up to the deplorable standard of referees so far this season. Webb was fu**ing terrible.

too true if you don't complain nothing will ever get done its a pity a few more don't lodge official complaints .

Alert a moderator to this post

Palace15eagle London 14 Mar 14 3.14pm
Quote Horley Eagle at 14 Mar 2014 1.27pm Swings and roundabouts. We got a double whammy against Swansea , not a pen, not a sending off so these things even themselves out over a season. It wasn't a pen no, but it was certainly a red card! Your HOL best newcomer of the year 2013. My twitter account: [Link]
Alert a moderator to this post

Palace15eagle

London 14 Mar 14 3.14pm

Quote Horley Eagle at 14 Mar 2014 1.27pm

Swings and roundabouts.

We got a double whammy against Swansea , not a pen, not a sending off so these things even themselves out over a season.

It wasn't a pen no, but it was certainly a red card!

Your HOL best newcomer of the year 2013.

My twitter account: [Link]

Alert a moderator to this post

jason7 croydon 14 Mar 14 3.21pm
This some you win some you lose crap is nonsense,Yes the pen at swansea was correct call by ref.On the other hand the sending of and pen at Old Trafford was not correct.They alter the whole game and need studying closer.
Alert a moderator to this post

jason7

croydon 14 Mar 14 3.21pm

This some you win some you lose crap is nonsense,Yes the pen at swansea was correct call by ref.On the other hand the sending of and pen at Old Trafford was not correct.They alter the whole game and need studying closer.

Alert a moderator to this post

Petereagle Brockley 14 Mar 14 3.22pm
Quote Laboureagle at 14 Mar 2014 12.53pm Why are we making an official complaint? The referee got some decisions wrong, but whining about it , we sound like sore losers and it looks demeaning for the club. There will be other games where the decisions go for us-its part of the game,we should just get on with it. Pulis is damned if he does (trouble maker) and damned if he doesnt (wimp). Personally I think hes right to complain, not that anything will change of course, we still got 0 points
Alert a moderator to this post

Petereagle

Brockley 14 Mar 14 3.22pm

Quote Laboureagle at 14 Mar 2014 12.53pm

Why are we making an official complaint? The referee got some decisions wrong, but whining about it , we sound like sore losers and it looks demeaning for the club. There will be other games where the decisions go for us-its part of the game,we should just get on with it.

Pulis is damned if he does (trouble maker) and damned if he doesnt (wimp). Personally I think hes right to complain, not that anything will change of course, we still got 0 points

Alert a moderator to this post

jason7 croydon 14 Mar 14 3.23pm
And if that means bringing our top ref in for a slating then so be it.He had a very bad day and this will sharpen him up.
Alert a moderator to this post

jason7

croydon 14 Mar 14 3.23pm

And if that means bringing our top ref in for a slating then so be it.He had a very bad day and this will sharpen him up.

Alert a moderator to this post

beer man Kent 14 Mar 14 3.54pm
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision. Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change. No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.
Alert a moderator to this post

beer man

Kent 14 Mar 14 3.54pm

Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm

Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change.

No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.

Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 14 Mar 14 4.05pm
Wasted exercise, as the referees association has assessors at all games, and their report will be final. So if Howard Webb was as bad as is said, "I have my doubts" the refs association would have already acted, and as he's ref at the Fulham v Newcastle match tomorrow they must consider he did ok.
Alert a moderator to this post

Sg Bilko

Deurne Holland 14 Mar 14 4.05pm

Wasted exercise, as the referees association has assessors at all games, and their report will be final.

So if Howard Webb was as bad as is said, "I have my doubts" the refs association would have already acted, and as he's ref at the Fulham v Newcastle match tomorrow they must consider he did ok.

Alert a moderator to this post

Mapletree Croydon 14 Mar 14 4.07pm
Quote beer man at 14 Mar 2014 3.54pm Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision. Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change. No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else. I see a logical flaw in your 'just go somewhere else' analogy with match officials, it's a monopoly. And anyway, when does feedback become whingeing? The opposite to doing something about it is moaning but doing nothing. Which is worse, being a moaner or a whinger, there's only one way to find out ....
Alert a moderator to this post

Mapletree

Croydon 14 Mar 14 4.07pm

Quote beer man at 14 Mar 2014 3.54pm

Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm

No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.

I see a logical flaw in your 'just go somewhere else' analogy with match officials, it's a monopoly.

And anyway, when does feedback become whingeing? The opposite to doing something about it is moaning but doing nothing. Which is worse, being a moaner or a whinger, there's only one way to find out ....

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Pulis makes official complaint about Howard Webb

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors