This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Stirlingsays 06 Apr 22 11.55am | |
---|---|
What I found amusing was Steely going from a very pro Russia position to then an anti one. Swaying so heavily to opposite positions is kind of indicative of not really having much conviction in the original position in the first place. I think with Steely he has an inbuilt almost reflex anti establishment or perhaps more accurately anti 'anglo saxon' position. So it takes quite a lot for him to end up supporting it.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Eaglecoops CR3 06 Apr 22 11.58am | |
---|---|
When you see them abroad, they are not average Russians. They are part of the rich elite which makes up a tiny minority of the country. They treat everyone like crap because that’s what they are allowed to get away with at home. They give it the big ‘un when they are out until you square up to them and then all of a sudden they can speak English and attempt to talk their way out of it. My lasting impression of my visit to Moscow, apart from being followed everywhere because I was with my high ranking treasury official mate and the Night Flight nightclub (interesting place!), was that you either drive a Bentley or a Trabant. There doesn’t seem to be much in the middle. Those who have, do what they want, those who don’t, really do not have much of an existence. Don’t really like them as a people, certainly the least friendly I’ve ever come across.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stirlingsays 06 Apr 22 12.02pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Russias attack on freedoms makes ours look like freedom central and the fact that Russians are not allowed to know, nor say that this war and accompanying atrocities have been carried out in their name is quite sad. As a country they are very much masters of self harm. Taking out innocent men, women and children with hands tied behind their backs is not how most would wish their nations to be perceived.
Russia isn't a democracy and it doesn't have a free press. Then again the Ukraine was not a shining light either and is a highly corrupt state which has been suffering from ceaseless foreign meddling for decades now. You refer to the Russian public not being told about atrocities carried out by their troops. I agree with that. However, that's also true in Ukraine and in the west. There is video of war crimes and terrible terrible events that media haven't reported upon because it also doesn't suit narratives. If you think the Russians are the only ones tieing people up and then butchering them then from what I've seen you're only half right.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stirlingsays 06 Apr 22 12.45pm | |
---|---|
Here is an image showing a more realistic picture of where the world is in regards to this war. Attachment: divided.JPG (65.92Kb)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
BlueJay UK 06 Apr 22 12.49pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Russia isn't a democracy and it doesn't have a free press. Then again the Ukraine was not a shining light either and is a highly corrupt state which has been suffering from ceaseless foreign meddling for decades now. You refer to the Russian public not being told about atrocities carried out by their troops. I agree with that. However, that's also true in Ukraine and in the west. There is video of war crimes and terrible terrible events that media haven't reported upon because it also doesn't suit narratives. If you think the Russians are the only ones tieing people up and then butchering them then from what I've seen you're only half right. Nobody is saying that terrible things don't take place in war or that the Ukraine is perfect, but there is a clear aggressor in this situation, at this time. If an intruder breaks into your home and kills people but also loses their own life, I don't have as much time for said intruders fate or how it came about in comparison to the lives they took. I certainly wouldn't consistently spend time constructing a case against or leafing through the past of those that live there, as the only feasible reason for doing so would be to underplay or reason away the aggressors behaviour. You clearly have a lot of time for Russia as a society. It doesn't much bother you that freedom of speech is very limited, because it's limited in a way that you're extremely comfortable with. Your 'anti mainstream' stance is an emptied cup that is inevitably filled with something else, but you should equally scrutinise what that is, rather than automatically assume that you're engaging in a forensic examination of truth that others simply 'don't get'. While it's perfectly reasonable to criticise the mainstream, the government, your countrymen, I feel with some that's ever on the rise to the point where they essentially just look for opportunities to do the West down and any situation it is supportive of. As I say, the irony is that you certainly wouldn't be doing that in Russia.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stirlingsays 06 Apr 22 1.12pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Nobody is saying that terrible things don't take place in war or that the Ukraine is perfect, but there is a clear aggressor in this situation, at this time. If an intruder breaks into your home and kills people but also loses their own life, I don't have as much time for said intruders fate or how it came about in comparison to the lives they took. I certainly wouldn't consistently spend time constructing a case against or leafing through the past of those that live there, as the only feasible reason for doing so would be to underplay or reason away the aggressors behaviour.
A war crime is a war crime and I reject your mitigations. We are not talking about edge cases here. There is a reason a Geneva convention exits and that doesn't just apply to troops belonging to the side you agree with. Originally posted by BlueJay
You clearly have a lot of time for Russia as a society. It doesn't much bother you that freedom of speech is very limited, because it's limited in a way that you're extremely comfortable with. Said with absolutely no evidence at all.....complete waffle. At no point have I supported Putin's Russia as some kind of 'better' in this war, but this doesn't seem to have filtered through to you. Originally posted by BlueJay
Given the choice, Your 'anti mainstream' stance is an emptied cup that is inevitably filled with something else, but you should equally scrutinise what that is, rather than automatically assume that you're engaging in a forensic examination of truth that others simply 'don't get'. While it's perfectly reasonable to criticise the mainstream, the government, your countrymen, I feel with some that's ever on the rise to the point where they essentially just look for opportunities to do the West down and any situation it is supportive of. As I say, the irony is that you certainly wouldn't be doing that in Russia. You have previously said on Hol that you take in different perspectives in media....but I think reading your takes, both on Covid and now this war I think I can realistically call that as a bluff. I don't actually think you do. Both instances saw you as pretty much a mainstream narrative supporter. It's kind of irritating to be called anti western by a centralist/leftist. I'm very much pro western, but that's its people not its self interested elites. I'm against decisions that harm my people. I don't sit upon some lofty moralistic mountain like you pretending that 'the right thing' (whatever that is) ultimately wins out. No, I care about doing the least amount of harm to those I care about. What you can say about me is that I don't automatically trust my own media anymore....that is a fair statement. Seemingly unlike you I do take in more than one perspective but I don't trust those either, however it allows me to reach more of a realistic position rather than being a cheer leader for one.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
PalazioVecchio south pole 06 Apr 22 2.05pm | |
---|---|
is the outcome below in keeping with the overall plans of Putin or Joe Biden ? and is it staged or propaganda ? just some innocent fun or Putin attempting to stir up things ? the comments underneath suggest it's not Fake News. Edited by PalazioVecchio (06 Apr 2022 2.17pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
BlueJay UK 06 Apr 22 2.18pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You have previously said on Hol that you take in different perspectives in media....but I think both reading your takes, both on Covid and now this war I think I can realistically call that as a bluff. I don't actually think you do. Both instances saw you as pretty much a mainstream narrative supporter. It's kind of irritating to be called anti western by a centralist/leftist. I'm very much pro western, I against decisions that harm my people. I sit upon some lofty moralistic mountain like you pretending that 'the right thing' (whatever that is) ultimately wins out. No, I care about doing the least amount of harm to those I care about. What you can say about me is that I don't automatically trust my own media anymore....that is a fair statement. Seemingly unlike you I do take in more than one perspective but I don't trust those either, however it allows me to reach more of a realistic position rather than being a cheer leader for one.
So that's that done. Who's 'your people' today then? White English? I mean with your positive attitudes towards groups that wish to deport non white British born individuals, it's certainly not other races is it? But what about white English of other sexualities who you deem to be 'degenerates' and 'f@ggots', routinely insulting members of your own family in the process (again). I'll avoid getting into disability as a topic but essentially it echoes the above. You don't seem to find much kinship with those white English on the left and centre, politically shunning the likes of Maples kind offers. The list goes on.. You care about 'doing the least amount of harm to those you care about'? Yeah right, you care about having the loudest voice in the room and being seen as more intrinsically valuable or entitled than others based on nothing. You're happy to do the opposite of care if that dynamic is unsettled. Getting drawn in by Kremlin seeded Tucker Carlson propaganda and the like. You can paint your stance as 'realistic' all you want, and do down others, but you're mistaken. You've just becoming detached from your own country on multiple fronts in some profound sense and so have more time for 'foreign' sources. I don't sit upon on a moral mountain at all, I just interact with enough people to know how to treat my countrymen regardless of colour, and creed and I elevate and support my family rather than do them down. It's not that hard. I love my country, for all that is it. I don't need to take a time machine back 50 or 60 years to appreciate it. You absolutely praise aspects of Russia, Hungary and the likes more than you ever do the West and seem affronted by the acknowledgement of current facts on the ground in Ukraine. Undermining what is happening to its people. I'm not going to sugarcoat Russia's conduct; I'll leave that to you.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
BlueJay UK 06 Apr 22 2.33pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
is the outcome below in keeping with the overall plans of Putin or Joe Biden ? and is it staged or propaganda ? just some innocent fun or Putin attempting to stir up things ? the comments underneath suggest it's not Fake News. Edited by PalazioVecchio (06 Apr 2022 2.17pm) Surely what's more likely is that these Ukranian students are simply being introduced to others. It looks like a class or college setting. This idea that they are literally 'speed dating' in some sort of romantic or sexual way doesn't make a lot of sense. Also if these were white students would it have been titled that way and would you have posted it? Looking for some kind of 'scary black man' angle at a picture of people sat at a table. It seems not to have much to do with the crux of the matter in terms of this invasion.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stirlingsays 06 Apr 22 3.01pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by BlueJay
My post was quite reasonable, but you seem to be in 'act up' mode. Fair enough. If you want to branch out into every topic under the sun so be it.
So that's that done. Yes, we both had the same position on lockdown.....and yes, you weren't a vocal supporter of kids being vaccinated. However, I was a far far louder critic of that. You would let WE support this position multiple times without ever countering it for example.....now I'm not saying you should attack your own side but personally I didn't regard covid as a political topic.. You also seemed to attack anyone who wished to raise doubts or skepticism. Over heart inflammation for example, when I raised that as a particular concern you posted to cast doubt on the concern.....subsequently I think events have rather weighed in my favour. Originally posted by BlueJay
Who's 'your people' today then? White English? I'd imagine the number of non white people calling themselves English is pretty low. Regardless, my people are English/British/European in degrees of concern. After that it extends out to the rest of humanity. Originally posted by BlueJay
I mean with your positive attitudes towards groups that wish to deport non white British born individuals, it's certainly not other races is it? You and your obsession with introducing PA into any topic you can. I am not an egalitarian like you....I see the harm that has done to the west. However, it is not true to say that I have no care for other races. We are all humans and I support social conservatives of any race. That however does not mean that I support my land being turned into a global village because egalitarians would feel better about themselves. Originally posted by BlueJay
And it's certainly not countrymen of other sexualities who you deem to be 'degenerates' and 'f@ggots' is it, routinely insulting members of your own family in the process (again). I'll avoid getting into disability as a topic but essentially it echoes the above. I'm quite happy calling you a fag and a degenerate if it equals it up for you. I'll say what I like about who I like. I notice you were quite happy to refer to dying people as 'prats' so I'll take no lectures from the likes of you on appropriate language. Originally posted by BlueJay
You don't seem to find much kinship with those in the left and centre, politically shunning the likes of Maples kind offers. Is that so? Well, I quite like Silvertop and as for Maple, I wouldn't say I'd shunned him.....Kinship? That's a bit gay isn't it? These are political discussions over text, not a fellowship. I think this is you being so thin skinned on pushback that you come out with hyperbolic nonsense. Originally posted by BlueJay
The list goes on.. In your emotive ranty mind it does. Originally posted by BlueJay
You care about 'doing the least amount of harm to those you care about'? Yeah right, you care about having the loudest voice in the room and being seen as more intrinsically valuable or entitled than others based on nothing. I think perhaps this says more about your insecurity than anything to do with how I see myself. Originally posted by BlueJay
Getting drawn in by Kremlin seeded Tucker Carlson propaganda and the like. You can paint your stance as 'realistic' all you want, and do down others, but you're mistaken. I agree with most of what Carlson thinks, yes that's accurate. I agree with most of what Orban thinks as well. The fact that you think that's 'Kermlin seeded' makes me laugh. As if being around and seeing actual events in history is 'Kermlin seeded'. Originally posted by BlueJay
You've just becoming detached from your own country on multiple fronts in some profound sense and so have more time for 'foreign' sources. I don't sit upon on a moral mountain at all, I just interact with enough people to know how to treat my countrymen regardless of colour, and creed and I elevate and support my family rather than do them down. It's not that hard. I love my country, for all that is it. I don't need to take a time machine back 50 or 60 years to appreciate it. You absolutely praise aspects of Russia, Hungary and the likes more than you ever do the West and seem affronted by the acknowledgement of current facts on the ground in Ukraine. Undermining what is happening to its people. I'm not going to sugarcoat Russia's conduct; I'll leave that to you. I'll do you the service of saying that I think you believe those things. Personally I don't think a commitment to objectivity and the truth is being anything other than adhering to the best western principles. I praise social conservatism that's true....apparently that should only relate to my own country now. To say I have 'sugarcoated' Russia's conduct, which I have criticised, is just more emotive and inaccurate comment.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
BlueJay UK 06 Apr 22 3.29pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I have to agree. My only experience of Russians was in the Maldives. They were rude, obnoxious and had trophy women who looked as sinister as the men. Plenty of the same page for a change on an issue
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
BlueJay UK 06 Apr 22 3.30pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Rather long post but a very familiar story. My few interactions with Russians have predominantly been abroad. I of course don't assume them all to be the same, however you do get that air of a cold, bitter, angrily saddened, isolated, anti-social, oppressed feel about them, as though they are determined to ensure whomever occupies similar space to them suffers a harsh reality reflecting their own life experiences. Quick anecdote, once a fellow holidaymaker I had ventured abroad with had a minor scuffle with a couple of Russian lads outside a bar on a 'strip' and soon found himself surrounded by about 10-15 of them. Through the night and the promenade's grapevine, the 10-15 or so of us who were abroad with him caught wind of this. I think the Russians get the impression the rest of Europe lives in some sort of mollycoddled luxury and therefore they have the upper hand in any physical confrontation. Their knowledge of areas such as Southwark, Lewisham and Woolwich is seriously lacking however and I think it soon dawned they'd 'bitten off more than they could chew'. To paint the proverbial picture, twas my younger self, the ubiquitous Liverpool fan, two Arsenal fans and 10 or so Millwall fans, who suffice to say led the victorious chanting post fracas which included what can only be described as a treasonous attempt at choruses of 'Rule Brittania', swiftly followed by long 'Miiiiilllllll' Doesn't sound like they'll forget you in a hurry .
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.