You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates
November 24 2024 3.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leader's debates

Previous Topic | Next Topic


Page 14 of 22 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

  

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 03 Apr 15 8.49pm Send a Private Message to Johnny Eagles Add Johnny Eagles as a friend

Harold Macmillan said people "had never had it so good" about the late 1950s.

My point is not that the 3 day week is worse than tuition fees. My point is that every generation has its challenges. Pensioners spent half their lives under threat of imminent nuclear destruction but you don't hear them demanding compensation policies from general election candidates.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 03 Apr 15 9.25pm Send a Private Message to Y Ddraig Goch Add Y Ddraig Goch as a friend

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2015 7.18pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Apr 2015 7.10pm

Alright, we do all like a moan and politics often amounts to just different interest groups moaning.

But I've thought about this a lot - there was an excellent radio 4 documentary about it a while ago - and I just don't accept that things are so bad or that "YOUNG PEOPLE" are so hard done by that it warrants specific policies or is a key general election.

Yes, there are problems (eg, housing and student debt) but that's life. My parents had problems too (eg, the 3 day week, IMF bailouts, growing up in a slum) and so did my grandparents did too (eg, the great depression and a world war).

You take the rough with the smooth. There's no human right to a university education or home ownership. The opportunities afforded today by cheap travel, the internet, better healthcare and new technology mean "YOUNG PEOPLE" are going to live longer, healthier and in many ways more fulfilling lives. Going after pensioners because they've got something you want is divisive and frankly I find it pitiful.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (03 Apr 2015 7.15pm)


I went through the three day weeks and I'm not a pensioner. It really wasn't that bad, as I recall it was about the same time that we had 'never had it so good'.

I'm not having a pop at pensioners. I am simply saying that there is in no way a level playing field for this generation. They don't get the benefits of the older generation and also have an overhang of debt created by them.

I would suggest that your memory is slightly clouded. Power cuts, manufacturers struggling. It was a fecking nightmare.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
TUX Flag redhill 03 Apr 15 9.41pm Send a Private Message to TUX Add TUX as a friend

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Apr 2015 8.49pm

Harold Macmillan said people "had never had it so good" about the late 1950s.

My point is not that the 3 day week is worse than tuition fees. My point is that every generation has its challenges. Pensioners spent half their lives under threat of imminent nuclear destruction but you don't hear them demanding compensation policies from general election candidates.


That would've left the ruling classes around the globe with nobody to rule. It was never going to happen then and it never will in future.
For many years now the 'threat' has been terrorism, recently dressed with an Ebola garnish.
More s***e to keep some in a state of panic.

Oh well.



Edited by TUX (03 Apr 2015 9.54pm)

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
imbored Flag UK 03 Apr 15 10.02pm

Grown men moaning about young people moaning. That didn't happen in my day .

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Quote this post in a reply
Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Apr 15 10.14pm Send a Private Message to Mapletree Add Mapletree as a friend

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Apr 2015 8.49pm

Harold Macmillan said people "had never had it so good" about the late 1950s.

My point is not that the 3 day week is worse than tuition fees. My point is that every generation has its challenges. Pensioners spent half their lives under threat of imminent nuclear destruction but you don't hear them demanding compensation policies from general election candidates.


Quite right. Age has clouded my memory. MacMillan was 57 and the three day week 74. Dammit, I have to agree with you again. Just don't let the pensioner generation say it's tougher for them than the current generation was my point. The middle class pensioners are now fat and happy, even if they did go through tough times.

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Apr 15 10.17pm Send a Private Message to Mapletree Add Mapletree as a friend

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 03 Apr 2015 9.25pm

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2015 7.18pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Apr 2015 7.10pm

Alright, we do all like a moan and politics often amounts to just different interest groups moaning.

But I've thought about this a lot - there was an excellent radio 4 documentary about it a while ago - and I just don't accept that things are so bad or that "YOUNG PEOPLE" are so hard done by that it warrants specific policies or is a key general election.

Yes, there are problems (eg, housing and student debt) but that's life. My parents had problems too (eg, the 3 day week, IMF bailouts, growing up in a slum) and so did my grandparents did too (eg, the great depression and a world war).

You take the rough with the smooth. There's no human right to a university education or home ownership. The opportunities afforded today by cheap travel, the internet, better healthcare and new technology mean "YOUNG PEOPLE" are going to live longer, healthier and in many ways more fulfilling lives. Going after pensioners because they've got something you want is divisive and frankly I find it pitiful.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (03 Apr 2015 7.15pm)


I went through the three day weeks and I'm not a pensioner. It really wasn't that bad, as I recall it was about the same time that we had 'never had it so good'.

I'm not having a pop at pensioners. I am simply saying that there is in no way a level playing field for this generation. They don't get the benefits of the older generation and also have an overhang of debt created by them.

I would suggest that your memory is slightly clouded. Power cuts, manufacturers struggling. It was a fecking nightmare.


Yeah, a nasty three months until the miners were given a 35% pay rise.

And we have just gone through what exactly?

And as a teenager, it was magic. Lots of family time by candlelight.

Edited by Mapletree (03 Apr 2015 10.20pm)

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
TUX Flag redhill 03 Apr 15 10.30pm Send a Private Message to TUX Add TUX as a friend

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2015 10.17pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 03 Apr 2015 9.25pm

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2015 7.18pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Apr 2015 7.10pm

Alright, we do all like a moan and politics often amounts to just different interest groups moaning.

But I've thought about this a lot - there was an excellent radio 4 documentary about it a while ago - and I just don't accept that things are so bad or that "YOUNG PEOPLE" are so hard done by that it warrants specific policies or is a key general election.

Yes, there are problems (eg, housing and student debt) but that's life. My parents had problems too (eg, the 3 day week, IMF bailouts, growing up in a slum) and so did my grandparents did too (eg, the great depression and a world war).

You take the rough with the smooth. There's no human right to a university education or home ownership. The opportunities afforded today by cheap travel, the internet, better healthcare and new technology mean "YOUNG PEOPLE" are going to live longer, healthier and in many ways more fulfilling lives. Going after pensioners because they've got something you want is divisive and frankly I find it pitiful.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (03 Apr 2015 7.15pm)


I went through the three day weeks and I'm not a pensioner. It really wasn't that bad, as I recall it was about the same time that we had 'never had it so good'.

I'm not having a pop at pensioners. I am simply saying that there is in no way a level playing field for this generation. They don't get the benefits of the older generation and also have an overhang of debt created by them.

I would suggest that your memory is slightly clouded. Power cuts, manufacturers struggling. It was a fecking nightmare.


Yeah, a nasty three months until the miners were given a 35% pay rise.

And we have just gone through what exactly?

And as a teenager, it was magic. Lots of family time by candlelight.

Edited by Mapletree (03 Apr 2015 10.20pm)

We've helped the rich get even richer.


 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Apr 15 11.58pm Send a Private Message to Willo Add Willo as a friend

My final message before I go to bed is :

"Don't let Labour wreck the progress we have made as a country.Let's stick with the plan and secure a better future for our country".

Goodnight !

 

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Apr 15 6.49am Send a Private Message to Kermit8 Add Kermit8 as a friend

Quote matt_himself at 03 Apr 2015 6.44pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 12.06pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 11.32am

Thank goodness Nigel was there to warn us all about all those foreigners with aids coming over here.


I was more worried about these '10 ex-communist countries' all upping sticks and coming over 'ere. And there was me thinking the Red Scare was a thing of the past!


Oh thankyou Nigel for saving us! "Swoon"


I have just got how much you lot are scared of Nigel and UKiP.

It makes perfect sense.

The left, of all hues, is intellectually and spiritually led by a comparatively rich & educated middle class clique. Miliband has two f***ing kitchens! The SWP and the Greens are middle class intellectuals playing Che Guevara. They have alienated the working class and detest the under class. The snobbery the left, of all hues, has towards these people, despite the the fact they are the marginalised groups these people claim to represent, has driven a wedge between the two.

Nigel is getting support from the working class and he underclass. He is able to represent them and his message is respected by these people. All the left can do is sling mud and claim Nigel is racist, bigoted and beyond contempt. But the left cannot offer an alternative who resonates with these people.

I am sure the response will be 'Lolz'. However the lefties in here know that I what I am saying is true and are privately wringing their hands and despairing that no one on their side can articulate an agenda and whose message resonates with the working and underclasses in a manner Nigel does.


There is plenty of apparent truth in that. However, dig a bit deeper and we will end up seeing the majority of working class people will vote Labour or Conservative as usual and the majority of the underclass will probably not vote at all.

So who exactly does Nige resonate with within those two groups? It's obviously not just 'working class' nor 'underclass' which is the only distinguishing feature which your post implies. They must have other things in common.

Maybe the charisma of Nige? Xenophobia? Dismay? Dislike of the EU?

I don't think class has anything to do with it really re:the UKIP vote. More how right wing one is and/or the seductiveness of Mr Farage.


And we are talking, at most, one in seven voters here. A sizeable amount but which also means, of course, six in seven have other affiliations. Being a democracy I'd rather hope that UKIP's power is not too much above their station as they don't represent 80-85% of voters.

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.07am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
matt_himself Flag Matataland 04 Apr 15 7.12am Send a Private Message to matt_himself Add matt_himself as a friend

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Apr 2015 6.49am

Quote matt_himself at 03 Apr 2015 6.44pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 12.06pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 11.32am

Thank goodness Nigel was there to warn us all about all those foreigners with aids coming over here.


I was more worried about these '10 ex-communist countries' all upping sticks and coming over 'ere. And there was me thinking the Red Scare was a thing of the past!


Oh thankyou Nigel for saving us! "Swoon"


I have just got how much you lot are scared of Nigel and UKiP.

It makes perfect sense.

The left, of all hues, is intellectually and spiritually led by a comparatively rich & educated middle class clique. Miliband has two f***ing kitchens! The SWP and the Greens are middle class intellectuals playing Che Guevara. They have alienated the working class and detest the under class. The snobbery the left, of all hues, has towards these people, despite the the fact they are the marginalised groups these people claim to represent, has driven a wedge between the two.

Nigel is getting support from the working class and he underclass. He is able to represent them and his message is respected by these people. All the left can do is sling mud and claim Nigel is racist, bigoted and beyond contempt. But the left cannot offer an alternative who resonates with these people.

I am sure the response will be 'Lolz'. However the lefties in here know that I what I am saying is true and are privately wringing their hands and despairing that no one on their side can articulate an agenda and whose message resonates with the working and underclasses in a manner Nigel does.


There is plenty of apparent truth in that. However, dig a bit deeper and we will end up seeing the majority of working class people will vote Labour or Conservative as usual and the majority of the underclass will probably not vote at all.

So who exactly does Nige resonate with within those two groups? It's obviously not just 'working class' nor 'underclass' which is the only distinguishing feature which your post implies. They must have other things in common.

Maybe the charisma of Nige? Xenophobia? Dismay? Dislike of the EU?

I don't think class has anything to do with it really re:the UKIP vote. More how right wing one is and/or the seductiveness of Mr Farage.

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.00am)

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.01am)


Look at the demographics of where UKIP support is strongest. Post industrial cities with high unemployment and coastal cities with B&B's full with people bussed in from other parts of the country.

Why would Farage be attractive to people living there? Because he listens to these people who have seen change and people forced upon their communities.

You will call it xenophobia because that is the simplistic and patronising response the left has for anyone voting UKIP. However, there are parts of the country that the establishment has effectively dumped. The left won't go there because they don't serve Freetrade coffee or Medjool Dates in the cafes in the towns. However, UKIP will go there, listen and sympathise with those whose lives have been changed because the neglect and snootiness of others.

The left looking down their noses at UKIP is acceptance that they have failed. They only have themselves to blame.

Edited by matt_himself (04 Apr 2015 7.16am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Apr 15 7.33am Send a Private Message to Kermit8 Add Kermit8 as a friend

Quote matt_himself at 04 Apr 2015 7.12am

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Apr 2015 6.49am

Quote matt_himself at 03 Apr 2015 6.44pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 12.06pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 11.32am

Thank goodness Nigel was there to warn us all about all those foreigners with aids coming over here.


I was more worried about these '10 ex-communist countries' all upping sticks and coming over 'ere. And there was me thinking the Red Scare was a thing of the past!


Oh thankyou Nigel for saving us! "Swoon"


I have just got how much you lot are scared of Nigel and UKiP.

It makes perfect sense.

The left, of all hues, is intellectually and spiritually led by a comparatively rich & educated middle class clique. Miliband has two f***ing kitchens! The SWP and the Greens are middle class intellectuals playing Che Guevara. They have alienated the working class and detest the under class. The snobbery the left, of all hues, has towards these people, despite the the fact they are the marginalised groups these people claim to represent, has driven a wedge between the two.

Nigel is getting support from the working class and he underclass. He is able to represent them and his message is respected by these people. All the left can do is sling mud and claim Nigel is racist, bigoted and beyond contempt. But the left cannot offer an alternative who resonates with these people.

I am sure the response will be 'Lolz'. However the lefties in here know that I what I am saying is true and are privately wringing their hands and despairing that no one on their side can articulate an agenda and whose message resonates with the working and underclasses in a manner Nigel does.


There is plenty of apparent truth in that. However, dig a bit deeper and we will end up seeing the majority of working class people will vote Labour or Conservative as usual and the majority of the underclass will probably not vote at all.

So who exactly does Nige resonate with within those two groups? It's obviously not just 'working class' nor 'underclass' which is the only distinguishing feature which your post implies. They must have other things in common.

Maybe the charisma of Nige? Xenophobia? Dismay? Dislike of the EU?

I don't think class has anything to do with it really re:the UKIP vote. More how right wing one is and/or the seductiveness of Mr Farage.

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.00am)

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.01am)


Look at the demographics of where UKIP support is strongest. Post industrial cities with high unemployment and coastal cities with B&B's full with people bussed in from other parts of the country.

Why would Farage be attractive to people living there? Because he listens to these people who have seen change and people forced upon their communities.

You will call it xenophobia because that is the simplistic and patronising response the left has for anyone voting UKIP. However, there are parts of the country that the establishment has effectively dumped. The left won't go there because they don't serve Freetrade coffee or Medjool Dates in the cafes in the towns. However, UKIP will go there, listen and sympathise with those whose lives have been changed because the neglect and snootiness of others.

The left looking down their noses at UKIP is acceptance that they have failed. They only have themselves to blame.

Edited by matt_himself (04 Apr 2015 7.16am)


But the vast majority of voters within the coastal towns and post-industrial places you refer to won't be voting UKIP. Your message only resonates enough to sway a few. You are making it out there is some kind of promised salvation going on out there. As if you really care. Codswallop. These neglected and depressed places should be voting for Nigel in their droves, shouldn't they? There are plenty of them too.

All you care about is getting enough votes/power/influence for an EU referendum. You don't give two hoots about Clacton.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply
matt_himself Flag Matataland 04 Apr 15 7.57am Send a Private Message to matt_himself Add matt_himself as a friend

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Apr 2015 7.33am

Quote matt_himself at 04 Apr 2015 7.12am

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Apr 2015 6.49am

Quote matt_himself at 03 Apr 2015 6.44pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 12.06pm

Quote serial thriller at 03 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Apr 2015 11.32am

Thank goodness Nigel was there to warn us all about all those foreigners with aids coming over here.


I was more worried about these '10 ex-communist countries' all upping sticks and coming over 'ere. And there was me thinking the Red Scare was a thing of the past!


Oh thankyou Nigel for saving us! "Swoon"


I have just got how much you lot are scared of Nigel and UKiP.

It makes perfect sense.

The left, of all hues, is intellectually and spiritually led by a comparatively rich & educated middle class clique. Miliband has two f***ing kitchens! The SWP and the Greens are middle class intellectuals playing Che Guevara. They have alienated the working class and detest the under class. The snobbery the left, of all hues, has towards these people, despite the the fact they are the marginalised groups these people claim to represent, has driven a wedge between the two.

Nigel is getting support from the working class and he underclass. He is able to represent them and his message is respected by these people. All the left can do is sling mud and claim Nigel is racist, bigoted and beyond contempt. But the left cannot offer an alternative who resonates with these people.

I am sure the response will be 'Lolz'. However the lefties in here know that I what I am saying is true and are privately wringing their hands and despairing that no one on their side can articulate an agenda and whose message resonates with the working and underclasses in a manner Nigel does.


There is plenty of apparent truth in that. However, dig a bit deeper and we will end up seeing the majority of working class people will vote Labour or Conservative as usual and the majority of the underclass will probably not vote at all.

So who exactly does Nige resonate with within those two groups? It's obviously not just 'working class' nor 'underclass' which is the only distinguishing feature which your post implies. They must have other things in common.

Maybe the charisma of Nige? Xenophobia? Dismay? Dislike of the EU?

I don't think class has anything to do with it really re:the UKIP vote. More how right wing one is and/or the seductiveness of Mr Farage.

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.00am)

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Apr 2015 7.01am)


Look at the demographics of where UKIP support is strongest. Post industrial cities with high unemployment and coastal cities with B&B's full with people bussed in from other parts of the country.

Why would Farage be attractive to people living there? Because he listens to these people who have seen change and people forced upon their communities.

You will call it xenophobia because that is the simplistic and patronising response the left has for anyone voting UKIP. However, there are parts of the country that the establishment has effectively dumped. The left won't go there because they don't serve Freetrade coffee or Medjool Dates in the cafes in the towns. However, UKIP will go there, listen and sympathise with those whose lives have been changed because the neglect and snootiness of others.

The left looking down their noses at UKIP is acceptance that they have failed. They only have themselves to blame.

Edited by matt_himself (04 Apr 2015 7.16am)


But the vast majority of voters within the coastal towns and post-industrial places you refer to won't be voting UKIP. Your message only resonates enough to sway a few. You are making it out there is some kind of promised salvation going on out there. As if you really care. Codswallop. These neglected and depressed places should be voting for Nigel in their droves, shouldn't they? There are plenty of them too.

All you care about is getting enough votes/power/influence for an EU referendum. You don't give two hoots about Clacton.


Keep thinking that. It is thoughts and the subsequent lack of action from the left that will give votes to UKIP.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Alert Alert a moderator to this post Edit this post Quote this post in a reply

  

Page 14 of 22 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates