To get away from all the arguments about the HF and their tantrums I’d like to suggest to Steve Parish that he organises a Singing Section for when the new stand is ready. A singing section controlled by the club.
I would still have this section in the centre of the Lower Holmesdale but leave it open to anyone who wants to sit there including existing ST holders.
I would base the section on the Real Madrid one at the Bernabeu in that there would be conditions to have these seats ie the people would all have to wear club shirts ( these could be offered at a discount by the club ). Flags and drums can be made available and obviously they must also sing !
This section can be as large as you want depending on the interest.

This way we get the atmosphere but without the unnecessary black clothes and Ultra connotations. Any existing ST holders who don’t want to take part can be offered alternatives but at least they would have had the opportunity to keep their seats. It has worked in Madrid!

What do we think ?

For the few coldest months, how would you know if people were wearing the compulsory club shirts, as everyone would be layered up and with coats on

And would black coats be banned?

Laughable suggestion.

If you don't like the Ultras, fair enough, but don't try and force your personal revulsion on a whole stand of Palace fans

Ludicrous.

What!
No prawn sandwiches !

I didn’t know Northampton had a singing section !

That might work !