This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
Murray's the man round ear 02 Sep 16 8.57pm | |
---|---|
Ok so just listened to Kevin Day interview with Brentford podcast about his disappointment in Kaikai going out on loan again and his hope to see him breakthrough this season I'm glad that a relatively well known fan has expressed something I think a lot of other fans feel. Also, Pardew made a veiled threat to Johnny Williams to perform in the euros to get a chance this season. Well unless I'm missing something he did just that. I believe that Pardew believes that acadamies wrap players in cotton wool. He said he felt like an outsider by the players who came through the academy when he joined us from non league Anyway, want to thank Kevin Day for speaking up and expressing the joy a homegrown player coming through gives us fans. I started going to games in the late seventies, where we started a tradition that if we now abandon then it takes the joy out of it for me. Zaha and Puncheon are carrying that torch for now, but they're not going to be here forever. Lets at least give those who have the club at heart at least a fair opportunity. Without Zaha, its debatable we would be here Cheers
Johnny will return |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
eaglesmy1 slough 02 Sep 16 9.06pm | |
---|---|
Im all about giving players from the reserves a chance, but Kai Kai needs a year in the championship before he makes the jump and as much as I like him Jonny Williams will never make his mark in the first team, good euros or not he's just not good enough.. I do think Kai Kai wil but why give a youngster 10 mins every 3 games when he can play 90 mins week in week out, that's the best formula for development. Edited by eaglesmy1 (02 Sep 2016 9.07pm)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Boooo 02 Sep 16 9.10pm | |
---|---|
Both Kaikai and Boateng being sent away for the whole season signaled enough for me to hold him in contempt for our youngsters. Boateng in particular didn't look out of place against Swansea last year and would sure have put a season of gut busting than some who haven't so far. Give Kaikai the ball and at worst you have a scatty Bolasie, at best-who knows?
I refuse to believe there are that many people out there that can't spell. Too f**king lazy, that's what I think. |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Casual Orpington 02 Sep 16 9.11pm | |
---|---|
I'd be more interested in what Darren Day thinks.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
SurreyEagle16 Next Door 02 Sep 16 9.13pm | |
---|---|
I think there is a difference between enjoying the success of a 'home grown' player and just forcing them in because of it. Given the chance...I would love a squad of 25 born between Thornton Heath and South Norwood. But I would rather finish tenth with Cabaye and Townsend in the team than 18th with Williams and kaikai. Neither is a certainty but you get the point.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
matthau South Croydon 02 Sep 16 9.18pm | |
---|---|
looking at ya profile. kai kai is ya fav player you must go to a lot of youth games to have him as ya fav then sounds sarcy but not meant to be. Edited by matthau (02 Sep 2016 9.19pm)
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Stuart Shave Hampshire 02 Sep 16 9.20pm | |
---|---|
KaiKai is not ready for the PL. He has huge potential but has yet to even kick a ball in the Championship. This season playing regular football at that level will be invaluable to him and to us. Joniesta is a strange one, he just can't seem to get going with us without something or someone interrupting. Normally it's an injury and I did really hope this would be the season for him with us, but having picked up yet another injury in pre-season, I think it makes sense for him to go away for one last time and try and play a whole season without getting injured at a good club at a good level. Ipswich fans love him, and they play good football so he'll be a key player for them so if he can help Ipswich, maybe we can get the benefit next season - if not then I guess it will probably be time to let him go - there will certainly be plenty of takers.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
ThatPetrolRelation Ottawa 02 Sep 16 9.21pm | |
---|---|
It looks like there is a plan in place. Try the youngsters in League 2, then 1, then the Champs. And I think it's a good plan. Kaikai looked good some preseason games, invisible in others (same with Ladapo). I'd rather he shine in the Championship for 90 than come on for 10 minute cameos. JW has to show he can deliver regularly for 90min. It would be good if he can shine, but I'm doubtful. Also looks like they may have kept a spot open to try to sign a free agent DM. Again I agree, Boateng is promising, but has to show consistency over 90 min.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Bangell Oxford 02 Sep 16 9.42pm | |
---|---|
Possible scenario 1: Pardew isn't putting Williams and Kaikai in the first team because he's being deliberately vindictive. Possible scenario 2: Pardew isn't putting Williams and Kaikai in the first team because they're unproven at Prem level and aren't currently good enough, or would benefit more long-term by playing regularly in the lower leagues. Now, personally I'd have kept Kaikai and Boateng at Palace, but only because our squad is so f***ing thin in their positions that we need someone, anyone as back-up. But I really don't get why every decision anyone disagrees with on here will get put down to Pardew being some kind of evil megalomaniac.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
The_Aviator Rochester 02 Sep 16 9.51pm | |
---|---|
Originally posted by Bangell
Possible scenario 2: Pardew isn't putting Williams and Kaikai in the first team because they're unproven at Prem level and aren't currently good enough, or would benefit more long-term by playing regularly in the lower leagues. Now, personally I'd have kept Kaikai and Boateng at Palace, but only because our squad is so f***ing thin in their positions that we need someone, anyone as back-up. But I really don't get why every decision anyone disagrees with on here will get put down to Pardew being some kind of evil megalomaniac. You've pretty much hit the nail on the head. I think Kaikai looks good whenever I've seen him (or video clips online). Certainly he and Boateng looked very good against Bromley a month or so ago. But that's just it... is looking good against Bromley enough given the quality of our first team squad these days? But if... just what if... Kaikai were to come off the bench and do a Rashford? Alas, now we'll never know. Not this season at any rate.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
MrCParrot Taunton 02 Sep 16 9.59pm | |
---|---|
Personally I think the point of loans out is to see if any of the players take off at the club and look like a player we would actually sign. Lapado seems to have done just that this week and may it continue straight into our first team next year. The problem comes when they play in a lower league and that would count against them. Obviously playing in the Championship is an advantage but Joniesta competent at Ipswich has never quite made the right impression at Palace under several managers, he should permanently move to a club that loves him (nearly) as much as we do. KaiKai is playing in the championship at Brentford and we can only hope that he lives up to expectation. The aim for these is to knock our weakest players Appiah and Campbell out of the team Parrot
Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello" |
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
ColombianCharlie Bogota 02 Sep 16 10.00pm | |
---|---|
I think with the new rules scrapping emergency loans, to keep both Kaikai and Boateng to play bit part roles in our squad would have been immensely unfair on both. They're both at an age where they need to be playing regularly and whilst it would have been good to see them get minutes here and there, realistically would either have got into the starting 11? I think we chose the only option we had, and I am sure particularly in Kaikai's case, if he stars in the Championship this year he will definitely be in our manager's thoughts next season.
|
|
Alert a moderator to this post |
Registration is now on our new message board
To login with your existing username you will need to convert your account over to the new message board.
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2024 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.