Ref: Man U v Palace

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Man U v Palace

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

The Dolphin 26 Nov 18 1.08pm
The foul on Luca by Fellani was disgraceful and he was looking right at it! How Shearer and Wright weren't up in arms on MOD I will never know. Proper bad red card tackle in my book! Anthony Taylor who was the 4th official failed to send off the Watford player back in august when he fouled Wilf just a few minutes into the game! Hmmmmmmmmmmm!
Alert a moderator to this post

The Dolphin

26 Nov 18 1.08pm

The foul on Luca by Fellani was disgraceful and he was looking right at it!
How Shearer and Wright weren't up in arms on MOD I will never know.
Proper bad red card tackle in my book!
Anthony Taylor who was the 4th official failed to send off the Watford player back in august when he fouled Wilf just a few minutes into the game!
Hmmmmmmmmmmm!

Alert a moderator to this post

peterg Anerley 26 Nov 18 3.46pm
We need Willo to tell us why Fellaini's red-carder wasn't even a yellow and why the ref didn't book him. There must be some reason.... The right place at the right time
Alert a moderator to this post

peterg

Anerley 26 Nov 18 3.46pm

We need Willo to tell us why Fellaini's red-carder wasn't even a yellow and why the ref didn't book him. There must be some reason....

The right place at the right time

Alert a moderator to this post

eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Nov 18 3.56pm
Originally posted by peterg We need Willo to tell us why Fellaini's red-carder wasn't even a yellow and why the ref didn't book him. There must be some reason.... Fellaini WAS cautioned for tha assault on Mili, as you said should of been red, but heh ho it was at Salford so what do you expect. Shearer did state it should be red but Wright said its how your foot would normally be when you make a pass, Shearers reply was What, that high? This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
Alert a moderator to this post

eagleman13

On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Nov 18 3.56pm

Originally posted by peterg

We need Willo to tell us why Fellaini's red-carder wasn't even a yellow and why the ref didn't book him. There must be some reason....

Fellaini WAS cautioned for tha assault on Mili, as you said should of been red, but heh ho it was at Salford so what do you expect.

Shearer did state it should be red but Wright said its how your foot would normally be when you make a pass, Shearers reply was What, that high?

This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Alert a moderator to this post

stayloa Beckenham 26 Nov 18 6.43pm
I actually thought the referee was excellent. The tackle on Luka wasn't great and I could see how it would be red worthy but there didn't appear to be huge amounts of intent. He played advantage brilliantly and was fair and even with the yellows.
Alert a moderator to this post

stayloa

Beckenham 26 Nov 18 6.43pm

I actually thought the referee was excellent. The tackle on Luka wasn't great and I could see how it would be red worthy but there didn't appear to be huge amounts of intent.

He played advantage brilliantly and was fair and even with the yellows.

Alert a moderator to this post

tazzer Basingstoke 27 Nov 18 10.38am
Not sure if he was cautioned for it considering we didn’t even get a free kick for it!
Alert a moderator to this post

tazzer

Basingstoke 27 Nov 18 10.38am

Not sure if he was cautioned for it considering we didn’t even get a free kick for it!

Alert a moderator to this post

adrian b Landrindod, Wales 29 Nov 18 10.06pm
Originally posted by stayloa I actually thought the referee was excellent. The tackle on Luka wasn't great and I could see how it would be red worthy but there didn't appear to be huge amounts of intent. He played advantage brilliantly and was fair and even with the yellows. Excellent impartial post. Either referees are of the highest and honest character or the game stops. Just because I referee a game in Liverpool but live in Cardiff makes no difference. If the league really believe a ref is not up to it the ref would not be selected game after game. We must assume the ref did not see the incident clearly and to make a decision when not seeing it would be dishonest.
Alert a moderator to this post

adrian b

Landrindod, Wales 29 Nov 18 10.06pm

Originally posted by stayloa

I actually thought the referee was excellent. The tackle on Luka wasn't great and I could see how it would be red worthy but there didn't appear to be huge amounts of intent.

He played advantage brilliantly and was fair and even with the yellows.

Excellent impartial post. Either referees are of the highest and honest character or the game stops. Just because I referee a game in Liverpool but live in Cardiff makes no difference. If the league really believe a ref is not up to it the ref would not be selected game after game.
We must assume the ref did not see the incident clearly and to make a decision when not seeing it would be dishonest.

Alert a moderator to this post

peterg Anerley 02 Dec 18 1.23pm
The Fellaini foul on Luka was far worse than the one Mounie was sent off for yesterday at Huddersfield. Fellaini was lucky not to get a red, Mounie was unlucky that he did. The right place at the right time
Alert a moderator to this post

peterg

Anerley 02 Dec 18 1.23pm

The Fellaini foul on Luka was far worse than the one Mounie was sent off for yesterday at Huddersfield. Fellaini was lucky not to get a red, Mounie was unlucky that he did.

The right place at the right time

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Ref: Man U v Palace

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors