Getting Wilshere to replace Cabaye = madness!

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Getting Wilshere to replace Cabaye = madness!

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

I'mPalace Till I Die 05 Jul 18 2.53am
Originally posted by pssguy Guaranteed starting spot Manager who picked him for England Style of play under Hodgson would suit him Chance to play with Zaha Doesn't have to disrupt family by moving Having said that, he seems more like a West Ham pick up and the previous time he had a chance to join he chose Bournemouth (admittedly Pardew was manager then) Think with Cabaye going he is a more attractive proposition for the club. Maybe they are still harbouring hopes for RLC who didn't boost his standing with Belgium display and had Dier picked ahead of him as sub v Colombia Edited by pssguy (04 Jul 2018 10.51pm) RLC is a different type of player to Dier. It was purely tactical, as opposed to being picked ahead of
Alert a moderator to this post

I'mPalace Till I Die

05 Jul 18 2.53am

Send a Private Message to I'mPalace Till I Die

Originally posted by pssguy

Guaranteed starting spot
Manager who picked him for England
Style of play under Hodgson would suit him
Chance to play with Zaha
Doesn't have to disrupt family by moving

Having said that, he seems more like a West Ham pick up and the previous time he had a chance to join he chose Bournemouth (admittedly Pardew was manager then)

Think with Cabaye going he is a more attractive proposition for the club. Maybe they are still harbouring hopes for RLC who didn't boost his standing with Belgium display and had Dier picked ahead of him as sub v Colombia

Edited by pssguy (04 Jul 2018 10.51pm)

RLC is a different type of player to Dier. It was purely tactical, as opposed to being picked ahead of

Alert a moderator to this post

essetwentyone london 05 Jul 18 7.22am
Cabaye not re-signing was always on the cards and therefore no surprise. He did a great job for us and will always have the fans admiration. Whoever buys Wilshere will surely want reassurance of his fitness and only take him on with injury recurrence clauses. Wilshere in turn will want a big signing on fee and wages to reflect the money saved by no transfer fee being paid - it’s just a calculation by which the buying club gets a cheaper deal but the player gets the money instead of his previous club. With that in mind I can’t see why we can’t go for him - he would be a great buy. It’s a fact that he gets on with Roy and with Wet Spams recent turmoil we are a more stable club. Let’s go for it if we can afford it !
Alert a moderator to this post

essetwentyone

london 05 Jul 18 7.22am

Cabaye not re-signing was always on the cards and therefore no surprise. He did a great job for us and will always have the fans admiration.
Whoever buys Wilshere will surely want reassurance of his fitness and only take him on with injury recurrence clauses. Wilshere in turn will want a big signing on fee and wages to reflect the money saved by no transfer fee being paid - it’s just a calculation by which the buying club gets a cheaper deal but the player gets the money instead of his previous club.
With that in mind I can’t see why we can’t go for him - he would be a great buy. It’s a fact that he gets on with Roy and with Wet Spams recent turmoil we are a more stable club. Let’s go for it if we can afford it !

Alert a moderator to this post

Midlands Eagle 05 Jul 18 7.31am
Originally posted by essetwentyone Let’s go for it if we can afford it ! It shouldn't be a case of if we can afford it as we need to afford some class in midfield whether it's Wilshere or someone else. I do hope that we're not pinning our hopes for the season on this cheap Turkish lad as that could either be a brilliant move or suicide and isn't worth the risk
Alert a moderator to this post

Midlands Eagle

05 Jul 18 7.31am

Send a Private Message to Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by essetwentyone

Let’s go for it if we can afford it !

It shouldn't be a case of if we can afford it as we need to afford some class in midfield whether it's Wilshere or someone else.

I do hope that we're not pinning our hopes for the season on this cheap Turkish lad as that could either be a brilliant move or suicide and isn't worth the risk

Alert a moderator to this post

Hootie121082 Vrysoulles 05 Jul 18 8.33am
I think wilshire would be a good addition. He has the experience and think he's injury troubles could be behind him Edited by Hootie121082 (05 Jul 2018 8.36am) FEELING GLAD ALL OVER
Alert a moderator to this post

Hootie121082

Vrysoulles 05 Jul 18 8.33am

I think wilshire would be a good addition. He has the experience and think he's injury troubles could be behind him

Edited by Hootie121082 (05 Jul 2018 8.36am)

FEELING GLAD ALL OVER

Alert a moderator to this post

essetwentyone london 05 Jul 18 2.37pm
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle It shouldn't be a case of if we can afford it as we need to afford some class in midfield whether it's Wilshere or someone else. I do hope that we're not pinning our hopes for the season on this cheap Turkish lad as that could either be a brilliant move or suicide and isn't worth the risk By “afford it” I was referring to how much Wilshere would want but we also have to work to a budget no matter how good the player. Yes we need to cover Cabaye and maybe Loftus-Cheek if he’s not coming back but not at any price !
Alert a moderator to this post

essetwentyone

london 05 Jul 18 2.37pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It shouldn't be a case of if we can afford it as we need to afford some class in midfield whether it's Wilshere or someone else.

I do hope that we're not pinning our hopes for the season on this cheap Turkish lad as that could either be a brilliant move or suicide and isn't worth the risk

By “afford it” I was referring to how much Wilshere would want but we also have to work to a budget no matter how good the player.

Yes we need to cover Cabaye and maybe Loftus-Cheek if he’s not coming back but not at any price !

Alert a moderator to this post

Hrolf The Ganger 05 Jul 18 2.58pm
The big question mark over Wilshire is his physical condition. Can he play PL football weekly and stay fit? I'm not sure his history suggests that this is likely. It is always tempting to sign a player from a big club but perhaps we could get much better value for money elsewhere as we did with Milivojevic. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Jul 2018 2.59pm)
Alert a moderator to this post

Hrolf The Ganger

05 Jul 18 2.58pm

Send a Private Message to Hrolf The Ganger

The big question mark over Wilshire is his physical condition. Can he play PL football weekly and stay fit?

I'm not sure his history suggests that this is likely. It is always tempting to sign a player from a big club but perhaps we could get much better value for money elsewhere as we did with Milivojevic.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Jul 2018 2.59pm)

Alert a moderator to this post

pstrutt Busselton, WA 05 Jul 18 4.51pm
Originally posted by baldeagle73 If we already had Wiltshire and we replaced him with 32 year old cabaye that would be madness Although certainly more in keeping with the transfer policies of Crystal Palace FC. So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
Alert a moderator to this post

pstrutt

Busselton, WA 05 Jul 18 4.51pm

Originally posted by baldeagle73

If we already had Wiltshire and we replaced him with 32 year old cabaye that would be madness

Although certainly more in keeping with the transfer policies of Crystal Palace FC.

So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 2 of 2 << First < 1 2

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Getting Wilshere to replace Cabaye = madness!

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors