Grabban for £7m ?!!?

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Grabban for £7m ?!!?

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 3 of 3 << First < 1 2 3

sydtheeagle England 12 Jan 16 7.43am
Quote Qwijibo at 11 Jan 2016 11.32pm Quote Qwijibo at 11 Jan 2016 11.32pm Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 11 Jan 2016 6.25pm Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.23pm An interesting way of looking at it is this. We have three Premier League games and two FA Cup games in January. If we'd signed a top striker the day window opened for, say, 2 million more than he was worth (to tie up the deal quickly) it might be reasonable to assume that we'd get three extra points from those games (of course that's conjecture, but to make my point I have to do something) not to mention possibly another round in the Cup. Are those points worth .6 million each? Well, if at the end of the season they result in us finish two places higher in the table then we're in profit. Not starting an argument or anything. Just trying to give a framework for evaluating the sense in doing what Bournemouth have done. I think it probably is worth spending a little more to do your business earlier in the window. Others may disagree. I tend to agree, that was my point about getting them in early and playing. Grabban is a no brainer for me, the other two more risky but it's minimal when you look at the rewards. I think all transfers are a gamble. So many fail to reach the standard hoped, so getting 3 in is spreading the risk, rather than assuming your first choice is nailed on to settle in. As mentioned, staying up is worth 17 mill (plus Iturbe). I learnt these facts during Holloway's 'Scattergun' Period. There's a mental image And it's not a very nice one. Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
Alert a moderator to this post

sydtheeagle

England 12 Jan 16 7.43am

Quote Qwijibo at 11 Jan 2016 11.32pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 11 Jan 2016 6.25pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.23pm

An interesting way of looking at it is this.

We have three Premier League games and two FA Cup games in January. If we'd signed a top striker the day window opened for, say, 2 million more than he was worth (to tie up the deal quickly) it might be reasonable to assume that we'd get three extra points from those games (of course that's conjecture, but to make my point I have to do something) not to mention possibly another round in the Cup. Are those points worth .6 million each? Well, if at the end of the season they result in us finish two places higher in the table then we're in profit.

Not starting an argument or anything. Just trying to give a framework for evaluating the sense in doing what Bournemouth have done. I think it probably is worth spending a little more to do your business earlier in the window. Others may disagree.

I tend to agree, that was my point about getting them in early and playing. Grabban is a no brainer for me, the other two more risky but it's minimal when you look at the rewards.

I think all transfers are a gamble. So many fail to reach the standard hoped, so getting 3 in is spreading the risk, rather than assuming your first choice is nailed on to settle in. As mentioned, staying up is worth 17 mill (plus Iturbe).

I learnt these facts during Holloway's 'Scattergun' Period.

There's a mental image

And it's not a very nice one.

Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Alert a moderator to this post

spartakev2 Anerley 12 Jan 16 9.48am
Have to say if Palace spent 20m on those two, I wouldn't really be that impressed. Not convinced either will be a big hit in the premiership. May be proved wrong though, but seems a lot of money.
Alert a moderator to this post

spartakev2

Anerley 12 Jan 16 9.48am

Have to say if Palace spent 20m on those two, I wouldn't really be that impressed. Not convinced either will be a big hit in the premiership. May be proved wrong though, but seems a lot of money.

Alert a moderator to this post

cpj Kent 12 Jan 16 10.26am
Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.23pm An interesting way of looking at it is this. We have three Premier League games and two FA Cup games in January. If we'd signed a top striker the day window opened for, say, 2 million more than he was worth (to tie up the deal quickly) it might be reasonable to assume that we'd get three extra points from those games (of course that's conjecture, but to make my point I have to do something) not to mention possibly another round in the Cup. Are those points worth .6 million each? Well, if at the end of the season they result in us finish two places higher in the table then we're in profit. Not starting an argument or anything. Just trying to give a framework for evaluating the sense in doing what Bournemouth have done. I think it probably is worth spending a little more to do your business earlier in the window. Others may disagree. Couldn't agree more. Except in a very few cases, we've always left our business til the end of the window. Get the impression that we're not the most generous of payers (nothing wrong in that) so it's difficult to get players over the line. Only problem is that other clubs snap up the better players.
Alert a moderator to this post

cpj

Kent 12 Jan 16 10.26am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.23pm

An interesting way of looking at it is this.

Couldn't agree more. Except in a very few cases, we've always left our business til the end of the window. Get the impression that we're not the most generous of payers (nothing wrong in that) so it's difficult to get players over the line. Only problem is that other clubs snap up the better players.

Alert a moderator to this post

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Jan 16 10.34am
Quote Midlands Eagle at 12 Jan 2016 7.24am Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.36pm Quote Willo at 11 Jan 2016 6.33pm I know someone involved in transfer activity at Bournemouth but he doesn't give anything away ! All he said to me the other day was that he was on his way to see an agent but didn't divulge any name ! And I've known him for over 30 years ! I am informed that I know someone who knows someone who's involved in transfer activity. Oh, it's Willo... He hasn't got anything to say but will still say it anyway Having perused this, "Pots and kettles" sprung immediately to mind.
Alert a moderator to this post

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Jan 16 10.34am

Quote Midlands Eagle at 12 Jan 2016 7.24am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Jan 2016 6.36pm

Quote Willo at 11 Jan 2016 6.33pm

I know someone involved in transfer activity at Bournemouth but he doesn't give anything away ! All he said to me the other day was that he was on his way to see an agent but didn't divulge any name ! And I've known him for over 30 years !

I am informed that I know someone who knows someone who's involved in transfer activity. Oh, it's Willo...

He hasn't got anything to say but will still say it anyway

Having perused this, "Pots and kettles" sprung immediately to mind.

Alert a moderator to this post

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Jan 16 10.38am
Quote Midlands Eagle at 12 Jan 2016 7.27am I expect that Bournemouth conducted their transfer activity early in the window leaving them enough time to buy another if history repeats itself I have just been speaking to my friend at the club who is involved in transfer activity.He talked about the "Early Bird....." scenario and also commented about probably putting other clubs noses out of joint ! As for Afobe he says he has seen him play since he was 14. Edited by Willo (12 Jan 2016 10.39am)
Alert a moderator to this post

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Jan 16 10.38am

Quote Midlands Eagle at 12 Jan 2016 7.27am

I expect that Bournemouth conducted their transfer activity early in the window leaving them enough time to buy another if history repeats itself

I have just been speaking to my friend at the club who is involved in transfer activity.He talked about the "Early Bird....." scenario and also commented about probably putting other clubs noses out of joint !
As for Afobe he says he has seen him play since he was 14.

Edited by Willo (12 Jan 2016 10.39am)

Alert a moderator to this post

Lyons550 Shirley 12 Jan 16 2.28pm
Quote Willo at 11 Jan 2016 6.33pm Bournemouth sold Grabban to Norwich for £3 Mill and have brought him back in a £7 Mill deal. I know someone involved in transfer activity at Bournemouth but he doesn't give anything away ! All he said to me the other day was that he was on his way to see an agent but didn't divulge any name ! And I've known him for over 30 years ! The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
Alert a moderator to this post

Lyons550

Shirley 12 Jan 16 2.28pm