Palace transfers by Manager

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace transfers by Manager

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 13 Jun 21 11.08am
Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income) Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees Hollaway, Disaster What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss “That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
Alert a moderator to this post

Lanzo-Ad

Lanzarote 13 Jun 21 11.08am

Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income)

Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M

Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m

Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m

Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m

Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M

Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees

Hollaway, Disaster

What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss

“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Alert a moderator to this post

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Jun 21 11.36am
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income) Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees Hollaway, Disaster What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss Sakho was purchased whilst FDB was in charge. Some of the other signings highlighted were either 'Free' or minimal spend in PL terms. A minimal 'Net spend' whilst Mr Hodgson was at the club. Edited by Willo (13 Jun 2021 11.37am)
Alert a moderator to this post

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Jun 21 11.36am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income)

Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M

Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m

Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m

Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m

Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M

Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees

Hollaway, Disaster

What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss

Sakho was purchased whilst FDB was in charge.
Some of the other signings highlighted were either 'Free' or minimal spend in PL terms.
A minimal 'Net spend' whilst Mr Hodgson was at the club.

Edited by Willo (13 Jun 2021 11.37am)

Alert a moderator to this post

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Horsham 13 Jun 21 11.43am
Don't think it's fair to say Holloway was a disaster. He did make quite a few good transfers for us (Chamakh, Kevin Philips, Cameron Jerome, Puncheon, Dobbie, Jazz Richards, etc.) Although that being said, he was like a kid in a candy shop once we got in the prem which caused him to lose the dressing room. The biggest failure transfer-wise in recent years for me has to go to Pardew. With the exception of Souare (who the club was already interested in signing) and Wilf (who was already on loan at the club). The rest of Pardew's signings we overspent on / weren't good enough IMO.
Alert a moderator to this post

Speronilover69 8=D~~

Horsham 13 Jun 21 11.43am

Send a Private Message to Speronilover69 8=D~~

The biggest failure transfer-wise in recent years for me has to go to Pardew. With the exception of Souare (who the club was already interested in signing) and Wilf (who was already on loan at the club). The rest of Pardew's signings we overspent on / weren't good enough IMO.

Alert a moderator to this post

doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Jun 21 11.43am
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income) Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees Hollaway, Disaster What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss Firstly, Sakho was bought under FdB's tenure (1st Sep 17). As you rightly state, Hodgson wasn't appointed until 12th Sep 17, so Hodgson's spend is about half of what you've stated. I haven't checked the others - it was just that I was sure Sakho's loan was made permanent before Hodgson's arrival. Secondly, not sure what you are wanting. The quoting of total spends fails to take account of player price inflation. Pardew, relatively speaking spent a fortune compared to the rest of the list.
Alert a moderator to this post

doombear

Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Jun 21 11.43am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Players puchased by Manager in charge, Money spent (not income)

Freedman Jan 1st 2011 until Oct 28th 2012 Moxey,Murray,Dikgacoi,Parr,Ward,Ramage,Bolasie, Garvan,Moritz,Delaney,Gabbidon Total spent 1.3M

Pulis Nov 23rd 2013 until Aug 14th 2014 Hennessesey,Puncheon,Ledley,Dann Total spent 5.7m

Pardew 3 Jan 2015 until 22 Dec 2016Mutch,Souare,Chungi,Wilf,Cabaye,McCarthy(keeper),Townsend,Mandana,Tomkins, Benteke,Wickham Total spent 75m

Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m

Hodgdon 12 sep 2017 until May Sakho,Jach,Sorloth,Guaita,Kouyate,Meyer,Ayew,Cahill,McCarthy,Ferguson,Eze,Butland Total Spent 69M

Warnock got McArthur and Kelly on Frees

Hollaway, Disaster

What is anybody opinion on that list, Discuss

Firstly, Sakho was bought under FdB's tenure (1st Sep 17). As you rightly state, Hodgson wasn't appointed until 12th Sep 17, so Hodgson's spend is about half of what you've stated. I haven't checked the others - it was just that I was sure Sakho's loan was made permanent before Hodgson's arrival.

Secondly, not sure what you are wanting. The quoting of total spends fails to take account of player price inflation. Pardew, relatively speaking spent a fortune compared to the rest of the list.

Alert a moderator to this post

rollercoaster Cornwall 13 Jun 21 5.24pm
I would like THE OP to Provide the breakdown of spend during Hodgson's tenure. Even minus Sakho I would be very surprised if the spend on transfer fees was actually that much
Alert a moderator to this post

rollercoaster

Cornwall 13 Jun 21 5.24pm

I would like THE OP to Provide the breakdown of spend during Hodgson's tenure. Even minus Sakho I would be very surprised if the spend on transfer fees was actually that much

Alert a moderator to this post

Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 13 Jun 21 6.33pm
Originally posted by rollercoaster I would like THE OP to Provide the breakdown of spend during Hodgson's tenure. Even minus Sakho I would be very surprised if the spend on transfer fees was actually that much All the information was from HOL and Wikipedia, Sakho missed all of FDBs matches, we signed him before FBD was here, he was signed initially in the close season, and it was actually agreed while still injured with ligament damage, so sorry i did get Roy's purchase wrong. but the others are there for all to see “That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
Alert a moderator to this post

Lanzo-Ad

Lanzarote 13 Jun 21 6.33pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

I would like THE OP to Provide the breakdown of spend during Hodgson's tenure. Even minus Sakho I would be very surprised if the spend on transfer fees was actually that much

All the information was from HOL and Wikipedia, Sakho missed all of FDBs matches, we signed him before FBD was here, he was signed initially in the close season, and it was actually agreed while still injured with ligament damage, so sorry i did get Roy's purchase wrong. but the others are there for all to see

Alert a moderator to this post

glaziermart 13 Jun 21 11.17pm
Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~ Don't think it's fair to say Holloway was a disaster. He did make quite a few good transfers for us (Chamakh, Kevin Philips, Cameron Jerome, Puncheon, Dobbie, Jazz Richards, etc.) Although that being said, he was like a kid in a candy shop once we got in the prem which caused him to lose the dressing room. The biggest failure transfer-wise in recent years for me has to go to Pardew. With the exception of Souare (who the club was already interested in signing) and Wilf (who was already on loan at the club). The rest of Pardew's signings we overspent on / weren't good enough IMO. That was not his fault. Parish brought a ridiculous amount of players in the August window, because we had not planned our targets properly in pre-season, so Holloway ended up with a unbalanced squad, some players he did not want, so a lot of the team spirit was lost.
Alert a moderator to this post

glaziermart

13 Jun 21 11.17pm

Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~

Don't think it's fair to say Holloway was a disaster. He did make quite a few good transfers for us (Chamakh, Kevin Philips, Cameron Jerome, Puncheon, Dobbie, Jazz Richards, etc.) Although that being said, he was like a kid in a candy shop once we got in the prem which caused him to lose the dressing room.

The biggest failure transfer-wise in recent years for me has to go to Pardew. With the exception of Souare (who the club was already interested in signing) and Wilf (who was already on loan at the club). The rest of Pardew's signings we overspent on / weren't good enough IMO.

That was not his fault. Parish brought a ridiculous amount of players in the August window, because we had not planned our targets properly in pre-season, so Holloway ended up with a unbalanced squad, some players he did not want, so a lot of the team spirit was lost.

Alert a moderator to this post

OneMax Maidstone 20 Jun 21 4.08am
Amazing that all of these are still at Palace (PVA only just) after five years. Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m
Alert a moderator to this post

OneMax

Maidstone 20 Jun 21 4.08am

Amazing that all of these are still at Palace (PVA only just) after five years.
Big Sam 23 Dec until 2016 until 23 May 2017 Schlupp,PVA,Luka Total spent 34m

Alert a moderator to this post

southnorwoodhill 20 Jun 21 7.42am
Dougie Fredman the winner hands down
Alert a moderator to this post

southnorwoodhill

20 Jun 21 7.42am

Send a Private Message to southnorwoodhill

Dougie Fredman the winner hands down

Alert a moderator to this post

Midlands Eagle 20 Jun 21 8.42am
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill Dougie Freedman the winner hands down He shouldn't really be included as he didn't manage in the Premier League
Alert a moderator to this post

Midlands Eagle

20 Jun 21 8.42am

Send a Private Message to Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Dougie Freedman the winner hands down

He shouldn't really be included as he didn't manage in the Premier League

Alert a moderator to this post

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Palace transfers by Manager

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors