Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

Pete53 Hassocks 04 Jan 20 3.31pm
If he does get a chance he's going to be a bit rusty having had no first team game time. Reidewald was a bit wobbly when he came into the side when injuries resulted in Roy remembering he was on our books , however he he has improved. If Camarasa doesn't feature in the cup game tomorrow then I don't think we will ever see him again and we will be left with a memory of one League Cup appearance and one Prem. League sub. appearance ( I think I am right in saying).Marginally better than Florian Marange but not by much.
Alert a moderator to this post

Pete53

Hassocks 04 Jan 20 3.31pm

If he does get a chance he's going to be a bit rusty having had no first team game time.

Reidewald was a bit wobbly when he came into the side when injuries resulted in Roy remembering he was on our books , however he he has improved.

If Camarasa doesn't feature in the cup game tomorrow then I don't think we will ever see him again and we will be left with a memory of one League Cup appearance and one Prem. League sub. appearance ( I think I am right in saying).Marginally better than Florian Marange but not by much.

Alert a moderator to this post

NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Jan 20 3.55pm
Originally posted by susmik As I said to stay in the premier league as he is doing and also as I did say! What I would do differently is use the youngsters by feeding them in slowly and not have them stuck on the bench for 90 odd minutes. Roy does not like to blood them for some reason unlike Chelsea who have tried all their young ones and are doing quite well to date. Roy has players that have come in during a couple windows but because his style is different he will not play them or they only get one or two matches a season. He always sticks with Benteke saying he WILL come good and start scoring. This is B/S as Roy sets up the team to suit him which we ALL know does not work so we have the same old same old week in week out. You only have to read other posts on this subject and I NOT alone in my thinking. Roy is good for keeping us in this division but do not expect top six or silverware!! Please don't compare Chelsea's youngsters with ours. It's not a fair comparison. Their young players consist of some of the cream of their age group which have been loaned out to aid their development and are now receiving game time largely because of the recent transfer ban. The likes of Hudson-Odoi were threatening to leave because he wasn't being selected and he's considered one of the top young talents in the country ! I can't make a case for Roy's football being consistently attractive to watch, but it is effective and the means have so far justified the ends. I know there is an element on here that like to do nothing but moan about Hodgson. He's not perfect but he's doing a great job in the circumstances, and I'm surprised that someone like yourself that claims to be such a long time fan can't give him the credit he deserves. And I certainly don't expect silverware or a top six finish, we don't have the financial resources to achieve that at this moment in time.And even that doesn't guarantee anything - as West Ham or Everton fans. Old, Ungifted and White
Alert a moderator to this post

NEILLO

Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Jan 20 3.55pm

Originally posted by susmik

As I said to stay in the premier league as he is doing and also as I did say! What I would do differently is use the youngsters by feeding them in slowly and not have them stuck on the bench for 90 odd minutes. Roy does not like to blood them for some reason unlike Chelsea who have tried all their young ones and are doing quite well to date.
Roy has players that have come in during a couple windows but because his style is different he will not play them or they only get one or two matches a season. He always sticks with Benteke saying he WILL come good and start scoring. This is B/S as Roy sets up the team to suit him which we ALL know does not work so we have the same old same old week in week out. You only have to read other posts on this subject and I NOT alone in my thinking.
Roy is good for keeping us in this division but do not expect top six or silverware!!

Please don't compare Chelsea's youngsters with ours. It's not a fair comparison. Their young players consist of some of the cream of their age group which have been loaned out to aid their development and are now receiving game time largely because of the recent transfer ban. The likes of Hudson-Odoi were threatening to leave because he wasn't being selected and he's considered one of the top young talents in the country !

I can't make a case for Roy's football being consistently attractive to watch, but it is effective and the means have so far justified the ends. I know there is an element on here that like to do nothing but moan about Hodgson. He's not perfect but he's doing a great job in the circumstances, and I'm surprised that someone like yourself that claims to be such a long time fan can't give him the credit he deserves.

And I certainly don't expect silverware or a top six finish, we don't have the financial resources to achieve that at this moment in time.And even that doesn't guarantee anything - as West Ham or Everton fans.

Old, Ungifted and White

Alert a moderator to this post

doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Jan 20 5.02pm
Originally posted by NEILLO Please don't compare Chelsea's youngsters with ours. It's not a fair comparison. Their young players consist of some of the cream of their age group which have been loaned out to aid their development and are now receiving game time largely because of the recent transfer ban. The likes of Hudson-Odoi were threatening to leave because he wasn't being selected and he's considered one of the top young talents in the country ! I can't make a case for Roy's football being consistently attractive to watch, but it is effective and the means have so far justified the ends. I know there is an element on here that like to do nothing but moan about Hodgson. He's not perfect but he's doing a great job in the circumstances, and I'm surprised that someone like yourself that claims to be such a long time fan can't give him the credit he deserves. And I certainly don't expect silverware or a top six finish, we don't have the financial resources to achieve that at this moment in time.And even that doesn't guarantee anything - as West Ham or Everton fans. I'm with youy there Neillo. We've done remarkably well to have stayed in the Premier League as long as we have in this spell. Progress will be at a snail's pace until we sort out the long term priorities.
Alert a moderator to this post

doombear

Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Jan 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I'm with youy there Neillo. We've done remarkably well to have stayed in the Premier League as long as we have in this spell. Progress will be at a snail's pace until we sort out the long term priorities.

Alert a moderator to this post

susmik PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 05 Jan 20 10.22am
Originally posted by NEILLO Please don't compare Chelsea's youngsters with ours. It's not a fair comparison. Their young players consist of some of the cream of their age group which have been loaned out to aid their development and are now receiving game time largely because of the recent transfer ban. The likes of Hudson-Odoi were threatening to leave because he wasn't being selected and he's considered one of the top young talents in the country ! I can't make a case for Roy's football being consistently attractive to watch, but it is effective and the means have so far justified the ends. I know there is an element on here that like to do nothing but moan about Hodgson. He's not perfect but he's doing a great job in the circumstances, and I'm surprised that someone like yourself that claims to be such a long time fan can't give him the credit he deserves. And I certainly don't expect silverware or a top six finish, we don't have the financial resources to achieve that at this moment in time.And even that doesn't guarantee anything - as West Ham or Everton fans. Its like I said if you bothered to read it that Roy is doing his job by keeping us in the premiership but he needs to blood some of the youngsters just to see how they do in the first team. Its no good keep saying that our youngsters are cra@ compared to Chelsea. IF we do not try it we will never know. AS for being a long time fan I give credit where it is due and have said he is keeping us up which is one good thing but he needs to change his ways when it comes to him changing things if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact. Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.
Alert a moderator to this post

susmik

PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 05 Jan 20 10.22am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I can't make a case for Roy's football being consistently attractive to watch, but it is effective and the means have so far justified the ends. I know there is an element on here that like to do nothing but moan about Hodgson. He's not perfect but he's doing a great job in the circumstances, and I'm surprised that someone like yourself that claims to be such a long time fan can't give him the credit he deserves.

Its like I said if you bothered to read it that Roy is doing his job by keeping us in the premiership but he needs to blood some of the youngsters just to see how they do in the first team. Its no good keep saying that our youngsters are cra@ compared to Chelsea. IF we do not try it we will never know.
AS for being a long time fan I give credit where it is due and have said he is keeping us up which is one good thing but he needs to change his ways when it comes to him changing things if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact.

Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Alert a moderator to this post

Mapletree Croydon 05 Jan 20 10.32am
[quote=susmik;if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact. Against Norwich. 45, 60 and 83 minutes He does change according to needs and resources. But he has his game plan which largely is effective, increasingly so
Alert a moderator to this post

Mapletree

Croydon 05 Jan 20 10.32am

[quote=susmik;if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact.

Against Norwich. 45, 60 and 83 minutes

He does change according to needs and resources. But he has his game plan which largely is effective, increasingly so

Alert a moderator to this post

NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jan 20 11.12am
Originally posted by susmik Its like I said if you bothered to read it that Roy is doing his job by keeping us in the premiership but he needs to blood some of the youngsters just to see how they do in the first team. Its no good keep saying that our youngsters are cra@ compared to Chelsea. IF we do not try it we will never know. AS for being a long time fan I give credit where it is due and have said he is keeping us up which is one good thing but he needs to change his ways when it comes to him changing things if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact. Why does he '' need '' to ? And if you bothered to read my post which you clearly didn't fully comprehend, at no time did I say that Palace's youngsters were '' crap '' compared to Chelsea's. What I did say is that Chelsea have a group of young players among the best in the country - are you disputing that ? As for his use of subs, I think he has actually started to change things quicker now as per Mapletree's example. But don't let that stop you having another dig. Old, Ungifted and White
Alert a moderator to this post

NEILLO

Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jan 20 11.12am

Originally posted by susmik

Its like I said if you bothered to read it that Roy is doing his job by keeping us in the premiership but he needs to blood some of the youngsters just to see how they do in the first team. Its no good keep saying that our youngsters are cra@ compared to Chelsea. IF we do not try it we will never know.
AS for being a long time fan I give credit where it is due and have said he is keeping us up which is one good thing but he needs to change his ways when it comes to him changing things if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact.

Why does he '' need '' to ? And if you bothered to read my post which you clearly didn't fully comprehend, at no time did I say that Palace's youngsters were '' crap '' compared to Chelsea's. What I did say is that Chelsea have a group of young players among the best in the country - are you disputing that ?

As for his use of subs, I think he has actually started to change things quicker now as per Mapletree's example. But don't let that stop you having another dig.

Old, Ungifted and White

Alert a moderator to this post

Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 11.24am
Originally posted by Mapletree [quote=susmik;if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact. Against Norwich. 45, 60 and 83 minutes He does change according to needs and resources. But he has his game plan which largely is effective, increasingly so Yes and Hodgson has also been very consistent, lets see how the likes of Brighton and Sheffield.U appear late into next season, I'm quite upset with the prospect of Hodgson retiring due to his maturity because we will then be in the same boat and on the theme of subs Hodgson understands very well the mental state of a player when removed from a battle he has been perfect with it and we can see it with our consistency, his main problem and with us has been scoring the goals that his football deserves, we have been missing far too many opportunities and if we had scored just one more in every game we'd have everyone on here much more happy with him and many more points on the table ...just one silly miss turned into one goal!
Alert a moderator to this post

Tickled pink

Cornwall 05 Jan 20 11.24am

Originally posted by Mapletree

[quote=susmik;if we are doing poorly in a match and do his subs sooner than on 80 mins like he tends to do. Roy will never change and that is a fact.

Against Norwich. 45, 60 and 83 minutes

He does change according to needs and resources. But he has his game plan which largely is effective, increasingly so

Yes and Hodgson has also been very consistent, lets see how the likes of Brighton and Sheffield.U appear late into next season, I'm quite upset with the prospect of Hodgson retiring due to his maturity because we will then be in the same boat and on the theme of subs Hodgson understands very well the mental state of a player when removed from a battle he has been perfect with it and we can see it with our consistency, his main problem and with us has been scoring the goals that his football deserves, we have been missing far too many opportunities and if we had scored just one more in every game we'd have everyone on here much more happy with him and many more points on the table ...just one silly miss turned into one goal!

Alert a moderator to this post

doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jan 20 11.31am
Have we strayed too far away from the original question re Camarasa? If so, a new thread?
Alert a moderator to this post

doombear

Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jan 20 11.31am

Have we strayed too far away from the original question re Camarasa? If so, a new thread?

Alert a moderator to this post

Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 12.26pm
Originally posted by doombear Have we strayed too far away from the original question re Camarasa? If so, a new thread? I get the feeling Camarasa has that effect.
Alert a moderator to this post

Tickled pink

Cornwall 05 Jan 20 12.26pm

Originally posted by doombear

Have we strayed too far away from the original question re Camarasa? If so, a new thread?

I get the feeling Camarasa has that effect.

Alert a moderator to this post

Tom-the-eagle Croydon 05 Jan 20 1.11pm
Very odd he is not involved today. He played in the league cup and I thought he looked ok (they all looked sh@t) Guess that’s him done. "It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
Alert a moderator to this post

Tom-the-eagle

Croydon 05 Jan 20 1.11pm

Very odd he is not involved today.

He played in the league cup and I thought he looked ok (they all looked sh@t)

Guess that’s him done.

"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Alert a moderator to this post

fishbone London 05 Jan 20 1.19pm
I think his treatment has been appalling!!
Alert a moderator to this post

fishbone

London 05 Jan 20 1.19pm

I think his treatment has been appalling!!

Alert a moderator to this post

thai-eagle chiang mai 08 Jan 20 2.00am
It seems Camarasa is history - at least in our club. I had high hopes for him after watching Cardiff a couple of games before they were relegated. Can anyone please tell "the true story" why our manager constantly overlooked a type of player we sorely missed?
Alert a moderator to this post

thai-eagle

chiang mai 08 Jan 20 2.00am

It seems Camarasa is history - at least in our club. I had high hopes for him after watching Cardiff a couple of games before they were relegated.
Can anyone please tell "the true story" why our manager constantly overlooked a type of player we sorely missed?

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this

Site Map

New users

Existing users

Sponsors